Ehlenbach's Cheese Chalet in Deforest, WI

1.5 Year Medium Cheddar

$8.98

Aged for about 18 months. 1.5 year medium cheddar has a sharp flavor, smooth and creamy texture. Good for melting. 1 lb.

1.5 Year Medium Cheddar

$46.95

Aged for about 18 months. 1.5 year medium cheddar has a sharp flavor, smooth and creamy texture. Good for melting. 5.5 lbs.

10 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar

$25.98

10 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese. 1 lb.

15 Year EXTREME Sharp Cheddar

$42.98

You ask and you shall receive. For an EXTREME sharp cheddar, the oldest yellow cheese at Ehlenbach's is now 15 years old, with a wonderful taste that can literally knock your socks off! Our 15 yearr Aged Cheddar Cheese has a wonderful taste to it. One of our must try items. 1 lb.

2.5 Year Old Sharp Cheddar

$10.98

Aged for about 2.5 years. Sharp flavor, smooth texture. 1 lb.

2.5 Year Old Sharp Cheddar

$57.95

Aged for about 2.5 years. Sharp flavor, smooth texture. 5.5 lbs.

4 Year Old Very Sharp Cheddar

$13.98

Aged for about 4 years, Ehlenbach's 4 Year Aged Sharp Cheddar has a very sharp flavor with a dry texture. 1 lb.

4 Year Old Very Sharp Cheddar

$73.95

Aged for about 4 years, Ehlenbach's 4 Year Aged Sharp Cheddar has a very sharp flavor with a dry texture. 5.5 lbs.

5 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar

$14.98

White sharp cheddar aged for about 5 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 1 lb.

5 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar

$79.95

White sharp cheddar aged for about 5 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 5.5 lbs.

7 Year Old Extra Sharp Cheddar

$18.98

Extra sharp cheddar aged by us for 7 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 1 lb.

Beer Kaese Aged Brick

$12.98

German recipe cheese, similar to a young limburger. Strong flavor and potent smell.

Cave Cured Aged Brick

$12.98

Much like limburger cheese. Very strong flavor and potent smell.

5 Year Old Extreme Aged Swiss

$19.98

Aged by us for up to 5 years. Extreme strong flavor.

2 Year Old Aged Swiss

$15.98

Aged by us for up to 2 years. Very strong flavor.

Aged Gouda

$9.98

Aged for about 8-12 months. Has a stronger flavor than regular Gouda.

Sharp Cheddar Spread

$6.98

Try our 4 Year Sharp Cheddar Spread available in a 15 oz. tub for a sharper taste.

1lb. True Blue Cheddar

$9.98

Cheddar Cheese with Blue Cheese Added. If you can't decide which one to put on your steak or burger, why not have both!

Bourbon Blue Cheese

$26.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, blue cheese infused with Kentucky Bulleit Bourbon. 1.5 lb.

Bourbon Blue Cheese (8 0z.)

$9.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, blue cheese infused with Kentucky Bulleit Bourbon.

Buttermilk Blue Cheese

$15.98

Awarded Best Blue Cheese at the 2014 World Championship Cheese Contest, our Buttermilk Blue Cheese is made with fresh raw milk and aged for 2 months.

Garlicky Blue Cheese

$9.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, blue cheese infused with garlic.

Gorganzola Blue Cheese

$10.98

Semisoft; blue-green mold marbled throughout, our Gorganzola Blue Cheese is crumbly with a strong flavor. Aged 90+ days.

Hickory-Smoked Blue Cheese

$16.98

Ehlenbach's smoked blue cheese is hickory smoked on-site and sells incredibly well in our cheese store. Made for that blue cheese lover in your life! 1 lb.

Holy Ghost Blue Cheese

$9.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, Blue Cheese infused with Holy Ghost Chili Pepper Hot Sauce from Bushel and Peck's.

Maple Blue Cheese

$9.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, blue cheese infused with Pure Wisconsin Maple Syrup.

Sriracha Blue Cheese

$9.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, blue cheese infused with sriracha. 1.5 lbs.

Steakhouse Blue Cheese

$9.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, our Steakhouse blue cheese is injected with au jus and rubbed with our Steakhouse Seasoning blend. Great on steaks, burgers, salads.

Winnie the Blue Cheese

$9.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, blue cheese and 100% Natural Raw Wisconsin Honey.

Wisconsin Blue Cheese

$9.98

1.5 Year Medium Cheddar

$8.98

Aged for about 18 months. 1.5 year medium cheddar has a sharp flavor, smooth and creamy texture. Good for melting. 1 lb.

10 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar

$25.98

10 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese.

15 Year EXTREME Sharp Cheddar

$42.98

For an EXTREME sharp cheddar, the oldest yellow cheese at Ehlenbach's is now 15 years old, with a wonderful taste that can literally knock your socks off! Our 15 yr Aged Cheddar Cheese has a wonderful taste to it. One of our must try items. 5.5 lbs.

Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$15.98

1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in black wax.

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$12.98

1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

1lb. True Blue Cheddar

$9.98

Cheddar Cheese with Blue Cheese Added. If you can't decide which one to put on your steak or burger, why not have both.

2.5 Year Old Sharp Cheddar

$10.98

Aged for about 2.5 years. Sharp flavor, smooth texture. 1 lb.

2.5 Year Old Sharp Cheddar

$57.95

Aged for about 2.5 years. Sharp flavor, smooth texture.

Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$29.98

2 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in black wax.

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$22.98

2 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax Wheel

$32.98

3 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

4 Year Old Very Sharp Cheddar

$13.98

Aged for about 4 years, Ehlenbach's 4 Year Aged Sharp Cheddar has a very sharp flavor with a dry texture.

5 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar

$14.98

White sharp cheddar aged for about 5 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 1 lb.

7 Year Old Extra Sharp Cheddar

$18.98

Extra sharp cheddar aged by us for 7 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties!

Applewood Smoked Garlic Cheddar

$10.98

Applewood Smoked Garlic Cheddar. 1 lb.

Applewood Smoked Variety Pack

$9.98

Can't decide which one to have? You do not have to with this Variety pack that contains four of some of the most popular Wisconsin cheeses: Colby, Colby Jack, Mild Cheddar and Monterey Jack. 1 lb.

Blueberry Cheddar

$10.98

Great as a dessert cheese, our Blueberry Cheddar features white sharp cheddar with blueberries added.

Cranberry Cheddar

$10.98

Great as a dessert cheese, our Cranberry Cheddar Cheese features white sharp cheddar with cranberries added.

Double Jalapeno Cheddar

$9.98

Double Jalapeno Cheddar is a mild white cheddar with twice the jalapenos added.

Ghost Habanero Cheddar

$52.95

One of our hottest cheeses, our Ghost Habanero Cheddar is a mild cheddar with ghost chili and habanero peppers added. WARNING!!! Not for the faint of heart! 5.5 lbs.

Hickory Smoked Bacon Cheddar

$11.98

A great mix of Cheddar and Bacon. We then Hickory Smoke the product for even more flavor.

Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar

$12.98

White Cheddar with Blueberries added. We then Hickory Smoke the product for even more flavor.

Hickory Smoked Cranberry Cheddar

$12.98

White Cheddar with Cranberries added. We then Hickory Smoke the product for even more flavor!

Hickory Smoked Double Jalapeno Cheddar

$11.98

Our Double Jalapeno White Cheddar that is put through our Smokehouse. A smoked cheese with a kick.

Hickory Smoked Olive Cheddar

$11.98

White Cheddar with Olives added. We then Hickory Smoke the cheese for some extra flavor. 1 lb.

Mild Cheddar

$6.98

Aged for about 6 months. Mild and mellow flavor.

Portabello Mushroom and Chive Cheddar

$9.98

Another store favorite, our Portabello Mushroom and Chive Cheddar is a white cheddar cheese with Portabello Mushrooms Galore. Throw in some chive - YUM! 1 lb.

Smoked 5 Year Cheddar

$16.98

Smoked 5 Year Cheddar.

Smoked Cheddar Cheese

$9.98

Cheddar Cheese that has been hickory smoked.

Smoked 4 Year Cheddar

$14.95

Our very own 4 year old Sharp Cheddar that we Smoke on site! A great smoked cheese with a great Sharp flavor.

Smoked Swiss and Cheddar

$9.98

Mixture of swiss and cheddar that has been hickory smoked.

Tomato Basil Cheddar

$9.98

Mild cheddar cheese with dried tomato and basil added.

White Cheddar with Apricots and Ginger

$9.98

Here is a little something different for you to try. A mild cheddar with the sweetness of apricots and the kick of ginger. A great snacking treat.

1 lb. Nut Brown Ale

$14.98

A Welsh miners style cheese ? this pure white cheese is pressed, remilled, the curds are soaked in Bull Falls Brewery beers from Wausau, WI, then repressed, bandage wrapped and cave aged.

Horseradish Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. Horseradish Cheddar.

Apple Cinnamon Cheddar

$12.98

1 lb. Apple Cinnamon Cheddar A medium sharp cheddar with apples and cinnamon added. Excellent with apple pie or for just snacking.

Garlic and Dill Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. Garlic and Dill Cheddar A mild cheddar with garlic and dill added.

Horseradish and Chive Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. A mild white cheddar with horseradish and chives added. This a great ham sandwich cheese.

Olive Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. A mild white cheddar with black and green olives added.

Beer Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. Mild cheddar with real Wisconsin beer added.

Merlot Cheddar

$14.98

1 lb. Merlot Cheddar: Merlot wine infused cheddar cheese. When in curd form, the cheese is soaked in merlot, which seeps into the cracks and produces a red and white marble effect.

Smoked Pepper String Cheese

$9.98

14 oz. Cherrywood smoked pepper string cheese. Low moisture, part skim milk, jalapeno peppers added.

Cherrywood Smoked String Cheese

$9.98

1lb String cheese, cherrywood smoke flavor.

1lb Plain String Cheese

$8.98

Plain.

Salty Plain String Cheese

$8.98

1lb of Ehlenbach's popular plain string cheese, flavored with extra salt.

Cherrywood Smoked String Cheese Whips

$6.98

8 oz. Cherrywood smoked string cheese whips.

String Cheese Whips

$6.98

Specialty Cheese Spreads - 12 oz Cheddy Blue

$6.98

Cheddar and Blue cheese come together in this 12 oz. Cheddy Blue cheese spread. It was gone for a bit, but our maker has improved the recipe to make sure the blue cheese flavor shines!

Specialty Cheese Spreads - Apple Cinnamon

$5.98

Apple Cinnamon flavored cheese spread.

Specialty Cheese Spreads - Cranberry Orange

$5.98

Cranberry Orange flavored cheese spread.

Specialty Cheese Spreads - Garden Vegetable

$5.98

Garden Vegetable flavored cheese spread.

Specialty Cheese Spreads - Tailgater

$5.98

Tailgater cheese spread.

Port Wine Spread

$6.98

Cheddar Cheese spread with port wine added.

Specialty Cheese Spreads (7 oz.)

$5.98

Our very own creation! This item you have to taste it to believe it. A true triumph! Wisconsin Breakfast ? an amazing Maple Bacon Cream Cheese Spread.

Specialty Cheese Spreads (8 oz.)

$5.98

Our very own creation! This item you have to taste it to believe it. A true triumph! Wisconsin Breakfast ? an amazing Maple Bacon Cream Cheese Spread.

Sharp Cheddar Spread

$6.98

Try our 4 Year Sharp Cheddar Spread available in a 15 oz. tub for a sharper taste.

Swiss Almond Spread

$6.98

12 oz. Swiss cheese spread with pieces of almonds throughout.

Jalapeno Hot Pepper Spread

$6.98

12oz. Cheddar cheese spread with jalapeno peppers added.

Garlic and Herb Spread

$6.98

12oz. Cheddar spread with garlic and herbs added to it.

Horseradish Spread

$6.98

12 oz. Cheddar spread with horseradish added. (White horseradish spread does not have color added to it.)

Bacon Spread

$6.98

12 oz. Bacon flavored cheddar spread.

Applewood Smoked Variety Pack 1 lb.

$9.98

Variety pack that contains four of some of the most popular Wisconsin cheeses: Colby, Colby Jack, Mild Cheddar and Monterey Jack.

Applewood Smoked Variety Pack 5 lb.

$47.95

Variety pack that contains four of some of the most popular Wisconsin cheeses: Colby, Colby Jack, Mild Cheddar and Monterey Jack.

Habanero Jack - Plain

$8.98

Habanero Jack - Plain 1lb from Ehlenbachs Cheese Chalet.

Habanero Jack - Plain

$42.95

Habanero Jack - Plain 5 lbs. from Ehlenbachs Cheese Chalet.

Colby Longhorn

$6.98

Colby-Jack

$6.98

Colby Jack Cheese with pepperoni - a great combination.

$6.98

Buffalo Monterey Jack

$8.98

Monterey Jack

$7.98

Habanero Jack

$10.98

Monterey Jack cheese with habenero peppers added. HOT Ghost Habanero is Monterey Jack Cheese with Ghost Chili and Habanero Peppers added. For those people who love true heat, this is our hottest cheese. **WARNING** Not for the faint of heart.

XXX Habanero Jack

$10.98

1 lb. XXX Habanero Jack has three times the heat as our Habanero Jack.

Pepper Jack

$8.98

Monterey Jack cheese with jalapeno peppers added.

Morel Mushroom and Leek Jack

$10.98

Monterey Jack cheese with morel mushrooms and leeks added.

Vegetable Jack

$8.98

Monterey Jack cheese with garden vegetables added.

Apple Jack Cheese

$9.98

A mixture of Monterey Jack, Swiss, and Cheddar cheeses. This is a mild, semi-soft cheese.

Gouda

$8.98

Made with whole milk. Rich, buttery, slightly sweet flavor. Smooth, creamy texture.

Aged Gouda

$9.98

Aged for about 8-12 months. Has a stronger flavor than regular Gouda.

Hickory Smoked Colby Jack

$8.98

Award winning Co-Jack the we have Hickory Smoked. A win-win!

Hickory Smoked Colby Longhorn

$8.98

Award winning Colby that we Hickory Smoked for some extra flavor!

Smoked Gouda

$10.98

Gouda that has been hickory smoked.

Applewood Smoked Garlic and Herb Gouda

$11.98

Applewood Smoked Garlic & Herb Gouda

Smoked Habanero Jack

$10.98

A real kick! Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero Peppers and a Great kiss of Hickory Smoke.

Smoked Pepper Jack

$9.98

Hickory Wood Smoked Pepper Jack.

1 lb. Pantaleo Green Jack

$8.98

Roasted Pueblo Green Chilies and Creamy Monterey Jack, a Little Heat and a Hint of Garlic.

31 oz. Dill Pickles - Dill

$8.98

If you are a fan of pickles, you'll LOVE our Dill pickles, whether you like them hot or mild.

31 oz. Dill Pickles - Garlic and Onion

$8.98

If you are a fan of pickles, you'll LOVE our Garlic & Onion pickles, whether you like them hot or mild.

31 oz. Dill Pickles - Habanero

$8.98

If you are a fan of pickles, you'll LOVE our Habanero pickles, whether you like them hot or mild.

31 oz. Dill Pickles - Jalapeno

$8.98

If you are a fan of pickles, you'll LOVE our Jalapeno pickles, whether you like them hot or mild.

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Black Raspberry Jam

$5.98

Locally made Black Raspberry Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced).

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Blackberry Jam

$5.98

Locally made Blackberry Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced).

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Blackberry Jelly

$5.98

Locally made Blackberry Jelly that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jelly: (Jelly is made from fruit JUICE, with no fruit pieces in it.)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Blueberry Jam

$5.98

Locally made Blueberry Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced).

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Boysenberry Jam

$5.98

Locally made Boysenberry Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced).

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Choke Cherry Jelly

$5.98

Locally made Choke Cherry Jelly that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jelly: (Jelly is made from fruit JUICE, with no fruit pieces in it.)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Cranberry Jam

$5.98

Locally made Cranberry Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jelly: (Jelly is made from fruit JUICE, with no fruit pieces in it.)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Cranberry Jelly

$5.98

Locally made Cranberry Jelly that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jelly: (Jelly is made from fruit JUICE, with no fruit pieces in it.)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Elderberry Jelly

$5.98

Locally made Elderberry Jelly that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jelly: (Jelly is made from fruit JUICE, with no fruit pieces in it.)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Jalapeno Pepper Jelly

$5.98

Locally made Jalapeno Pepper Jelly that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jelly: (Jelly is made from fruit JUICE, with no fruit pieces in it.)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Raspberry and Jalapeno Jelly

$5.98

Locally made Raspberry & Jalapeno Jelly that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jelly: (Jelly is made from fruit JUICE, with no fruit pieces in it.)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Red Cherry Jam

$5.98

Locally made Red Cherry Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Red Raspberry Jam

$5.98

Locally made Red Raspberry Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Strawberry Jam

$5.98

Locally made Strawberry Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Strawberry and Rhubarb Jam

$5.98

Locally made Strawberry & Rhubarb Jam that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced)

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies - Strawberry and Rhubarb Jelly

$5.98

Locally made Strawberry & Rhubarb Jelly that is sure to please. One of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced)

Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup

$6.98

Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup. Wisconsin Maple Syrup aged in Bourbon Barrels from Central Waters Brewing Company located in Amherst, Wisconsin.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz. - Apple

$5.98

Our Apple fruit butters are made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, and are sure to please.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz. - Apricot

$5.98

Our Apricot fruit butters are made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, and are sure to please.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz. - Blueberry

$6.98

Our Blueberry fruit butters are made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, and are sure to please.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz. - Cherry

$5.98

Our Cherry fruit butters are made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, and are sure to please.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz. - Cinnamon Candy Apple

$5.98

Our Cinnamon Candy Apple fruit butters are made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, and are sure to please.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz. - No Sugar Apple

$5.98

Our Sugar FREE Apple fruit butters are made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, and are sure to please.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz. - Peach

$5.98

Our Peach fruit butters are made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, and are sure to please.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz. - Pumpkin

$5.98

Our Pumpkin fruit butters are made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, and are sure to please.

Our Own Barbecue Sauce - Flaming Hot

$5.98

Get ready for the ballpark! Our 20 oz. Flaming Hot Barbecue Sauce barbecue sauces will go great with some brats at your next tailgate or family grill out.

Our Own Barbecue Sauce - Smokin' Pit

$5.98

Get ready for the ballpark! Our 20 oz. Smokin' Pit Barbecue Sauce barbecue sauces will go great with some brats at your next tailgate or family grill out.

Our Own Barbecue Sauce - Stillin' Moonshine

$5.98

Get ready for the ballpark! Our 20 oz. Stillin' Moonshine BBQ Sauce barbecue sauces will go great with some brats at your next tailgate or family grill out.

Our Own Barbcue Sauce - Stinging Honey

$5.98

Get ready for the ballpark! Our 20 oz. Stinging Honey Barbecue Sauce barbecue sauces will go great with some brats at your next tailgate or family grill out.

Our Own Barbecue Sauce - Think-n-Sweet

$5.98

Get ready for the ballpark! Our 20 oz. Think-n-Sweet barbecue sauces will go great with some brats at your next tailgate or family grill out.

Salsa - Cherry

$7.98

You'll want to try our Cherry Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Corn

$7.98

You'll want to try our 16 oz. Corn Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Corn and Bean

$7.98

You'll want to try our Corn & Bean Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Cranberry

$7.98

You'll want to try our Cranberry Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Habanero

$7.98

You'll want to try our Habanero Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Hot Garden

$7.98

You'll want to try our Hot Garden Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Mango

$7.98

You'll want to try our Mango Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Medium Garden

$7.98

You'll want to try our Medium Garden Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Mild Garden

$7.98

You'll want to try our Mild Garden Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Peach

$7.98

You'll want to try our Peach Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Pineapple

$7.98

You'll want to try our Pineapple Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Salsa - Raspberry

$7.98

You'll want to try our Raspberry Salsa salsa. Made with the freshest ingredients.

Our Own Barbecue Sauce

$5.98

Get ready for the ballpark! Our 20 oz. barbecue sauces will go great with some brats at your next tailgate or family grill out.

Wisconsin Natural Acres Honey

$6.98

Wisconsin Natural Acres Honey is 100% Artisan All Natural pure. We never blend our honey with foreign or out of state honey. We never heat or filter our Honey. Heat and filtering can destroy honey's antioxidants and active enzymes. Available in Spreadable Raw Honey or Jar Natural Honey.

Beer Mustard

$6.98

This beer mustard goes wonderful with all cheese and sausage trays as well as just dipping pretzels into it.

Cherry Honey Mustard

$6.98

10oz. Cherry Honey Mustard This is our most popular mustard. This mustard goes wonderful with all cheese and sausage trays as well as just dipping pretzels into it. A sweet honey mustard with cherries added!

31 oz. Dill Pickles

$8.98

if you are a fan of pickles, whether you like them hot or mild, these are sure to please. The old fashioned way that pickles were made.

9-1/2oz. Jams and Jellies

$5.98

Locally made jams and jellies that are sure to please. Try one or more of our 16 flavors! Go ahead and spread it on a little thick. Jams: (Jams are made from quality fruit - whole or sliced.

Mustard

$3.98

The perfect compliment to any cheese and sausage. Also great for dipping.

Salsa

$7.98

You'll want to try these fantastic salsas. Made with the freshest ingredients. Corn & Black Bean Corn Salsa Black Bean Cherry Raspberry Cranberry Peach Pineapple Mild Garden Vegetable Medium Garden Vegetable Hot Garden Vegetable Habanero Mango.

Ehlenbach's Fruit Butters, 9.5 oz.

$5.98

Made especially for our store with real fruit for a home-made taste, our fruit butters are sure to please. These butters will complement bagels, crackers or toast.

Maple Syrup Jug

$10.98

100% Pure Wisconsin 'Grade A' Maple Syrup in plastic jug.

Fear the Reaper Cheddar 1 lb.

$13.98

One of our hottest cheeses, our Fear the Reaper is a mild cheddar with Carolina Reaper peppers added. WARNING!! Not for the faint of heart!

Ghost Habanero Cheddar 1 lb.

$10.98

One of our hottest cheeses, our Ghost Habanero Cheddar is a mild cheddar with ghost chili & habanero peppers added. WARNING!! Not for the faint of heart!

Mango Fire Cheddar

$12.98

A mild cheddar cheese with mango puree and habanero peppers.

Burning Desire

$12.98

1 lb. A processed cheese that contains Ghost Jack, Habanero Jack and Pepper Jack. This is our hottest cheeses. **WARNING** Not for the faint of heart.

1 lb. Hot Pepper Cheese

$7.98

White processed cheese with jalapeno peppers added. Has a nice kick to it.

Beef, Cheddar and Jalapeno Sticks

$9.98

8oz. Beef, Cheddar-n-Jalapeno Sticks, A 8 pack of the all beef stick that has it all. Jalapeno and cheddar make for a wonderful blast for the taste buds. A must try item.

Ehlenbach's Jalapeno Cheddar Landjaeger

$29.98

6 pair pack. Ehlenbach's Exclusive Recipe ? German style meat sticks with Jalapeno and Cheddar. (For a more dry and chewy texture, hang Landjaegers out to dry at room temperature?they do not require refrigeration.)

1 lb. Double Cream Brie

$12.98

Double Cream Brie Deliciously buttery and creamy inside, with a snow-white edible rind, mild with a subtle mushroom flavor.

Mozzarella

$5.98

Semisoft; smooth rubbery texture. Mild flavor. Made with part skim milk. Only 5 grams of fat per one ounce serving.

Provolone

$6.98

Firm, white cheese. Mild flavor. Great for sandwiches.

Parmesan

$14.98

Buttery, sweet, nutty flavor intensifies with age. Hard, granular texture. Aged over 10 months. Commonly used for shredding and grating.

Sarvecchio Parmesan

$17.98

Double aged parmesan. 22 months old or greater. A new way to enjoy parmesan.

1lb. Bellavitano Cheese

$17.98

One of Wisconsin's newest additions! A grating or snacking cheese that gives a new meaning to flavor. Excellent aftertaste that will get you hooked fast. Add it to pasta or just break it apart and go to town.

1lb. Chardonnay Bellavitano Cheese

$17.98

Bellavitano that is soaked in chardonnay wine to give the cheese bright and buttery notes of wine. The combination of Wisconsin Cheddar cheese and Parmesan give this cheese a terrific texture, somewhere between creamy and rich and crunchy and granular.

1lb. Raspberry Ale Bellavitano Cheese

$17.98

Bellavitano that is soaked in a Raspberry Tart Ale made locally by New Glarus Brewery. This gives the cheese nutty, brown-buttery flavors with bright sweet notes of ruby-red raspberries.

1lb. Rosemary Olive Oil Asiago

$17.98

An Italian inspired farmstead cheese made from pasteurized cow's milk, which has been hand-rubbed with rosemary and Italian olive oil. The flavor is a cross between a Parmesan and sharp white Cheddar with a savory high note complementing the rich, nutty and fruity flavor of Asiago.

1 lb. Tennessee Whiskey Bellavitano Cheese

$17.98

One of Wisconsin's newest additions, Bellavitano meets Tennessee Whiskey! A grating or snacking cheese full of spirit and smooth sweetness.

Asiago

$14.98

Commonly used as a grating cheese. Flavor similar to a blend of aged cheddar and parmesan.

1 lb. Romano

$14.98

A hard, salty grating cheese.

Hickory Smoked Mozzarella

$7.98

Ever tried a pizza with real Mozzarella that is Hickory Smoked. A new way to eat pizza!

Hickory Smoked Provolone

$8.98

Whole milk Provolone that we run through our Smokehouse! A great favorite!

Pecanwood Smoked Double Cream Brie

$14.98

Creamy Double Cream Brie that we use a Pecanwood to smoke. Becoming one of our most popualr Smoked cheeses!

Smoked Parmesan

$16.98

A New Creation for you Pasta dishes! Try our Hickory Smoked Parmesan grated on your next pasta dish. What can we say Perfecto!

Mozzarella

$5.98

Semisoft; smooth rubbery texture. Mild flavor. Made with part skim milk. Only 5 grams of fat per one ounce serving.

Farmers Cheese

$8.98

Low Fat Farmers Cheese.

1 lb. Lacey Swiss

$9.98

Low Fat Lacey Swiss has 6 grams of fat per one ounce serving.

1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$15.98

Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in black wax.

1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$12.98

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

2 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$29.98

Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in black wax.

2 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$22.98

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

3 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax Wheel

$32.98

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

4 oz. Black and White Cow Shape

$6.98

Mild cheddar cheese dipped in wax in the shape of a holstein cow.

1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$15.98

1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in black wax.

1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$12.98

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

2 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$29.98

Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in black wax.

2 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax

$22.98

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

3 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax Wheel

$32.98

Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.

Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup

$6.98

Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup. Wisconsin Maple Syrup aged in Bourbon Barrels from Central Waters Brewing Company located in Amherst, Wisconsin.

Holy Ghost Blue Cheese, 1.5 lb

$26.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, Blue Cheese infused with Holy Ghost Chili Pepper Hot Sauce from Bushel & Peck's.

Holy Ghost Blue Cheese, 8 oz

$9.98

An Ehlenbach's Exclusive, Blue Cheese infused with Holy Ghost Chili Pepper Hot Sauce from Bushel & Peck's.

XXX Habanero Jack

$10.98

1 lb. XXX Habanero Jack has three times the heat as our Habanero Jack.

Cranberry Blueberry Dried Venison

$14.98

8 oz. Cranberry Blueberry Dried Venison with Beef (may contain dried apples).

1 lb. Pantaleo Green Jack

$8.98

Roasted Pueblo Green Chilies and Creamy Monterey Jack, a Little Heat and a Hint of Garlic.

Burning Desire

$12.98

1 lb. A processed cheese that contains Ghost Jack, Habanero Jack and Pepper Jack. This is our hottest cheeses. **WARNING** Not for the faint of heart.

1 lb. Hot Pepper Cheese

$7.98

White processed cheese with jalapeno peppers added. Has a nice kick to it.

Smoked Horseradish Cheese

$9.98

A great Horseradish Cheese with Hickory Smoke. Leaving you with an amazing aftertaste.

Smoked Onion Cheese

$9.98

A Creamy Onion Cheese with a Great Hickory Smoke Kick.

1 lb. Caraway Swiss

$7.98

White processed swiss cheese with caraway seeds added.

1 lb. American Cheese

$7.98

Yellow processed cheese.

1 lb. Salami Cheese

$7.98

Yellow processed cheese with pieces of salami added.

1 lb. Onion Cheese

$7.98

White processed cheese with onions added.

1 lb. Pizza Cheese

$7.98

Yellow processed cheese with pizza seasonings added.

1 lb. Bacon Cheese

$7.98

Yellow processed cheese with pieces of bacon added. Nice smokey flavor.

Horseradish Cheese

$7.98

Processed, horseradish cheese.

Chocolate Cheese Fudge

$9.98

Our Original Chocolate Cheese Fudge With Nuts. Processed American Cheese with cocoa beans, sugar and walnuts added. Tastes just like fudge. Great as a dessert cheese or melted as a chocolate fondue. All flavors come in an 8 oz. piece.

1 lb. Garlic Cheese

$7.98

White processed cheese with garlic added. If you like garlic, you'll love this one!

Smoked Swiss and Cheddar 1 lb

$9.98

Mixture of swiss and cheddar that has been hickory smoked.

Smoked Swiss and Cheddar 2.25 lbs.

$21.95

Mixture of swiss and cheddar that has been hickory smoked.

Baby Swiss

$8.98

Young swiss with tiny holes and mild flavor.

Buttery Swiss

$12.98

Aged for about 8 months. Rich, buttery flavor. Great for slicing and melting.

Medium Swiss

$10.98

Aged for about 12 months. Medium strong flavor.

5 Year Old Extreme Aged Swiss

$19.98

Aged by us for up to 5 years. Extreme strong flavor.

2 Year Old Aged Swiss

$15.98

Aged by us for up to 2 years. Very strong flavor.

Smoked Baby Swiss

$9.98

Mild baby swiss that has been hickory smoked.

Applewood Smoked Buttery Swiss

$14.98

Our popular Buttery Swiss smoked on-site.

Pecanwood Smoked Swiss Gruyere

$19.98

Swiss Gruyere smoked on-site with pecanwood.

1 lb. Caraway Swiss

$7.98

White processed swiss cheese with caraway seeds added.

1 lb. Lacey Swiss

$9.98

Low Fat Lacey Swiss has 6 grams of fat per one ounce serving.

Swiss Gruyere

$17.98

Nutty, rich, full-bodied flavor. Firm texture with a few tiny holes. Most commonly used in cheese fondues and baked dishes.

1lb. True Blue Cheddar

$9.98

Cheddar Cheese with Blue Cheese Added. If you can't decide which one to put on your steak or burger, why not have both!

1 lb. Nut Brown Ale

$14.98

A Welsh miners style cheese ? this pure white cheese is pressed, remilled, the curds are soaked in Bull Falls Brewery beers from Wausau, WI, then repressed, bandage wrapped and cave aged.

1 lb. Double Cream Brie

$12.98

Double Cream Brie Deliciously buttery and creamy inside, with a snow-white edible rind, mild with a subtle mushroom flavor.

Mango Fire Cheddar

$12.98

A mild cheddar cheese with mango puree and habanero peppers.

Burning Desire

$12.98

1 lb. A processed cheese that contains Ghost Jack, Habanero Jack and Pepper Jack. This is our hottest cheeses. **WARNING** Not for the faint of heart.

Co-Jack Cheese and Pepperoni

$6.98

Colby Jack Cheese with pepperoni - a great combination.

Morel Mushroom and Leek Jack

$10.98

Monterey Jack cheese with morel mushrooms and leeks added.

5 Year Old Extreme Aged Swiss

$19.98

Aged by us for up to 5 years. Extreme strong flavor.

2 Year Old Aged Swiss

$15.98

Aged by us for up to 2 years. Very strong flavor.

Jalapeno Havarti

$10.98

Our famous Wisconsin havarti with jalapeno peppers added. The same creamy havarti with the kick of jalapeno peppers. Has become more popular than pepper jack.

1 lb. Bellavitano Cheese

$17.98

One of Wisconsin's newest additions! A grating or snacking cheese that gives a new meaning to flavor. Excellent aftertaste that will get you hooked fast. Add it to pasta or just break it apart and go to town.

1 lb. Chardonnay Bellavitano Cheese

$17.98

Bellavitano that is soaked in chardonnay wine to give the cheese bright and buttery notes of wine. The combination of Wisconsin Cheddar cheese and Parmesan give this cheese a terrific texture, somewhere between creamy and rich and crunchy and granular.

1 lb. Raspberry Ale Bellavitano Cheese

$17.98

Bellavitano that is soaked in a Raspberry Tart Ale made locally by New Glarus Brewery. This gives the cheese nutty, brown-buttery flavors with bright sweet notes of ruby-red raspberries.

1 lb. Rosemary Olive Oil Asiago

$17.98

An Italian inspired farmstead cheese made from pasteurized cow's milk, which has been hand-rubbed with rosemary and Italian olive oil. The flavor is a cross between a Parmesan and sharp white Cheddar with a savory high note complementing the rich, nutty and fruity flavor of Asiago.

1 lb.Tennessee Whiskey Bellavitano Cheese

$17.98

One of Wisconsin's newest additions, Bellavitano meets Tennessee Whiskey! A grating or snacking cheese full of spirit and smooth sweetness.

Apple Cinnamon Cheddar

$12.98

1 lb. Apple Cinnamon Cheddar A medium sharp cheddar with apples and cinnamon added. Excellent with apple pie or for just snacking.

Garlic and Dill Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. Garlic and Dill Cheddar A mild cheddar with garlic and dill added.

Pesto Havarti

$10.98

Creamy, semisoft with pin-sized holes. Pesto Havarti is an Ehlenbach's Exclusive and has basil and black pepper.

Horseradish and Chive Havarti

$10.98

Creamy, semisoft with pin-sized holes. Has a nice blend of horseradish and chives added.

Horseradish and Chive Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. A mild white cheddar with horseradish and chives added. This a great ham sandwich cheese.

Olive Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. A mild white cheddar with black and green olives added.

Beer Cheddar

$9.98

1 lb. Mild cheddar with real Wisconsin beer added.

Chicken Soup Cheese

$9.98

Mild white cheese with chicken flavored broth powder, onion, garlic, celery flakes, parsley and tumeric. Tastes just like chicken soup!

1 lb. Pantaleo Green Jack

$8.98

Roasted Pueblo Green Chilies and Creamy Monterey Jack, a Little Heat and a Hint of Garlic.

Chocolate Cheese Fudge

$9.98

Our Original Chocolate Cheese Fudge With Nuts. Processed American Cheese with cocoa beans, sugar and walnuts added. Tastes just like fudge. Great as a dessert cheese or melted as a chocolate fondue. All flavors come in an 8 oz. piece.