Godfather’s Pizza at 361 3rd St NW HARTLEY, IA 51346

Phone: (712) 728-2319

Address: 361 3rd St NW Hartley, IA 51346

American Pizza

Godfather's Pizza Menu in Hartley

Pizza - Our Sizes


Feeds 1-2 people. 6' approx 4 slices


Feeds 2-3 people. 10' approx 6 slices


Feeds 3-4 people. 12' approx 8 slices


Feeds 4-5 people. 14' approx 8-10 slices


Feeds 5-6 people. 18' approx 10-12 slices

Pizza - Our Sauces

Original Sauce

Our original pizza sauce is a blend of vine-ripened tomatoes 'cuz where else would they ripen, seasonings and a little bit of The Godfather's special touch.

Taco Sauce

Our taco sauce has just the right amount of South-of-the-Border kick.

Pizza - Our Toppings

Veggies and Stuff

Black olives, green olives, green peppers, jalapenos, mushrooms, onions, pineapple, sour cream, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, mozzarella

Meat Toppings

Anchovies, bacon bits, beef, ham, italian sausage, pepperoni, sausage

Pizza - Our Crusts


This thick, rich crust is what first made Godfather's Pizza so popular and is still a favorite today.


If you prefer pan-style pizza, then this crust is the only way to go. It's warm, buttery, and filling.


Light and crispy, our thin crust puts the toppings center stage

Our Specialties

As pizza pros, we have developed a line of specialty pizzas that will leave you wondering how you ever lived before. Each specialty pizza was carefully crafted to combine just the right ingredients to create a mouthwatering pizza that will keep you comin' back for more, and more, and more!

Classic Combo

The classic combo is what godfather's pizza is all about. This pizza is piled high with all da goods: pepperoni, sausage, beef, onions, black olives, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese.

Humble Pizza

The humble pizza is anything but humble. Loads of pepperoni, green peppers, Italian sausage, onions, and mozzarella make this simple pizza a pizza pie piled high.

Taco Pizza

Got a craving for something south of the border? The taco pizza is the only pizza that starts with a spicy taco sauce and is topped with beef, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese to create a unique flavor guaranteed to satisfy your craving.

All-Meat Combo

The All-Meat Combo is piled so high with beef, pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon bits that there's no room for any veggies.

Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

A pizza loaded with beef, onions, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese topped with bacon bits and sliced pickles creates a favorite bacon cheeseburger pizza.

Hot Stuff Pizza

Like it hot? Try a pizza topped with pepperoni, beef, italian sausage, jalapenos, and onions and you've got the makings of a hot stuff pizza.

Veggie Pizza

Here's a pizza especially for veggie lovers. Mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, black olives, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese?all crisp and fresh, our veggie Pie's got gobs of flavor.

Our Super Specialties

If you want to take the flavor to the next level, try one of our Super Specialties

Super Combo

Add ham, green peppers, tomatoes, and extra cheese to the classic combo and you get a pizza that is serious about deliverin da goods

Super Hawaiian

The warm flavors of Super Hawaiian seem to instantly transport you to your own private island. Let the combination of pineapple, baked ham, green peppers, bits of bacon, and mozzarella melt away your troubles and brighten your day.

Super Taco

Can't get enough of our spicy Taco Pizza? Then it's time to upgrade. Our Super Taco adds some black olives, sour cream, and even more cheese to create a pizza that's simply delicioso!

Gluten-Free Pizza

Godfather's Pizza is pleased to offer our gluten-free pizza available for dine-in, delivery, carryout, and even catering. Our gluten-free pizzas are available in six varieties: cheese, pepperoni, sausage, beef, all-meat combo and classic combo

Gluten-Free Pizza


Complete your meal with any one of our tasty and convenient sides.


Warm, buttery, and perfect for dipping in our famous marinara sauce.


A special blend of garlic, Italian seasoning, and lots of mozzarella cheese make our cheesesticks an appealing appetizer or entrée!

Garlic Bread

Crisp and buttery, there's nothing like a slice of our garlic bread to start your meal

Garlic Bread with cheese

Want even more flavor? Try our garlic bread with cheese. each slice is topped with a mix of cheeses for the perfect finishing touch.

Hot Wings

A ton of flavor with just the right amount of kick


A soft and chewy pocket stuffed with fresh veggies, meats, and lots of cheese.

Potato Wedges

Thick slices of potatoes seasoned and baked to a yummy, golden, crispy finish.

Italian Monkey Bread

When baked together, these bite-size pieces of seasoned dough become a soft, chewy, and mouth-poppin' treat.


Crisp lettuce, lots of fresh veggies, and scrumptious dressings. Suddenly, salads don't seem so bad


Need somethin sweet? Godfathers pizzas got you covered.


Whether you choose cinnamon or fruit, you are in for a special treat. We start with one of our famous pizza crust, smother it with cinnamon and sugar or fruit filling, and top it with delicious icing.

Cinnamon Monkey Bread

This dessert covers bite-size pieces of dough with cinnamon and sugar and bakes them together for a warm, tasty, and fun dessert.

Big Chocolate Chip Cookie

You can never go wrong with a classic! Our big chocolate chip cookie is soft and chewy with tons of gooey chocolate chips. Just like mom used to make, only much, much bigger!