Michael O'Toole's in Columbus, OH
Michael O'Toole's Restaurants with Address and Phone:
1 restaurant location in Columbus
Michael O'Toole's Menu in Columbus
Appetizers
Mike's Jumbo Wings
$8.99
tossed in your choice of mild, hot or tangy bbq sauce. served with celery and blue cheese dressing.
Louisiana Fried Oysters
$11.99
oysters with southern remoulade and tequila lime cocktail sauce.
French Dip Sliders
$12.99
thinly sliced prime rib topped with caramelized onions, mushrooms, provolone cheese and horseradish sauce.
Disco Fries
$7.99
topped with mushroom gravy, aged cheddar, sour cream and scallions.
Spicy Cajun Shrimp
$9.99
jumbo shrimp smothered in a cajun cream sauce served over a grilled baguette.
Potato Skins
$9.99
piled high with grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar cheese, green onion and sour cream.
Spinach And Artichoke Dip
$8.99
served with house made tortilla chips.
Soups
New England Clam Chowder
$4.99
Soup Of The Day
$4.99
Salads
Add grilled or blackened chicken 4.99 or salmon 8.99. Dressing choices: italian, bleu cheese, ranch, honey mustard, toasted sesame, raspberry or balsamic vinaigrette.
Ahi Tuna Salad
$11.99
asian inspired with toasted sesame vinaigrette, shiitake mushrooms, and crispy noodles on a nest of baby greens.
Cobb Salad
$10.99
topped with roasted turkey, ham, grilled chicken, egg, tomato, red onion, avocado and made-from-scratch croutons.
Candied Walnut Spinach Salad
$9.99
baby spinach with chopped egg, roma tomatoes, creamy gorgonzola cheese and raspberry balsamic vinaigrette.
Mixed Greens
$8.99
spring lettuce mix, gorgonzola crumbles, bacon, tomato and red onion tossed in a sweet pepper vinaigrette.
Michael's House Salad
$8.99
piled high with tomato, cucumber, carrot, egg, red onion, aged cheddar cheese and made-from scratch croutons.
Caesar Salad
$8.99
crisp hearts of romaine, fresh shaved parmesan cheese and made-from-scratch croutons tossed in our zesty caesar dressing.
Sandwiches
All burgers and sandwiches are served with boardwalk french fries or kettle chips.
Prime Rib French Dip O'Toole's
$12.99
own prime rib, shaved thin and stacked high with onion, mushrooms, provolone cheese, horseradish cream sauce and au jus.
Fisherman's Sandwich Battered
$11.99
cold water deep fried fish with lettuce, tomato and southern remoulade sauce.
Chicken Salad BLT
$9.99
our creamy chicken salad with crisp apple wood smoked bacon, lettuce and tomato served on a fresh baked croissant.
German Bologna Sandwich
$9.99
this 'thick cut' bologna sandwich is the best south of waldo, served with sliced dill pickle, red onion and spicy mustard.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$9.99
grilled chicken breast tossed in spicy buffalo sauce, topped with lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.
Stacked High Classic Reuben
$11.99
piled high with half pound of corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, 1000 island dressing on grilled marble rye.
Classic Meatloaf Sandwich
$10.99
wrapped with smoked bacon, topped with pepper jack cheese and tangy bbq sauce. served with lettuce, tomato and red onion.
O'Toole's Classic Club
$9.99
sliced turkey, ham, apple wood smoked bacon, swiss and cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. (house made garlic mayonnaise available).
Sausage Hoagie
$9.99
sweet italian sausage smothered with peppers and onions. served on a toasted hoagie roll.
Burgers
All burgers and sandwiches are served with boardwalk french fries or kettle chips.
Michael O'Toole's Burger
$8.99
with lettuce, tomato, red onion and house made garlic mayonnaise.
Bacon Cheeseburger
$9.99
topped with smoked apple wood bacon, choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion and house made garlic mayonnaise.
Coal Miners Cheeseburger
$9.99
stacked with apple wood smoked bacon, colossal onion rings, cheddar cheese and smothered with bbq sauce.
Mushroom & Swiss Burger
$9.99
a blend of sauteed mushrooms, swiss cheese and a hint of truffle oil. topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and onion.
Flame Broiled Veggie Burger
$8.99
black bean burger topped with lettuce, tomato, avocado and house made garlic mayonnaise served on our house brioche bun.
Michael's Combo
Michael's Combo
$9.99
pick any half sandwich and your choice of soup or salad. small michael's house salad, new england clam chowder, soup of the day, 1/2 stacked high classic reuben, 1/2 o'toole's classic club, 1/2 chicken salad blt.
Prime Rib & Steaks
All of michael o'tooles steaks are served with whipped potatoes. Top your steak: house infused garlic butter $1.00, sauce bearnaise 2.00, black & bleu $2.00, sauteed mushrooms & onions $4.00.
Slow Roasted Prime Rib
$28.99
served daily after 5pm.
6oz Filet Mignon
$23.99
8 Oz Sirloin
$21.99
16 Oz Bone-In Ribeye
$28.99
12 Oz New York Strip
$26.99
Lamb Porterhouse
$22.99
Main Course
Chilean Sea Bass
$22.99
pan-seared and oven baked, served with sauteed fresh vegetables, wild rice and finished with a savory lemon butter sauce.
Mom's Famous Meatloaf
$15.99
wrapped with apple wood bacon and covered in mushroom gravy, served over whipped potatoes and sauteed fresh vegetables.
'Lake Erie Walleye Fish & Chips'
$17.99
an ohio fisherman's delight with a twist, deep fried golden brown served with boardwalk fries, house made coleslaw and remoulade sauce.
Stuffed Chicken Breast
$15.99
a whole roasted airline chicken breast stuffed with prosciutto and gorgonzola cheese and served with sauteed fresh vegetables and wild rice.
Cajun Shrimp & Angel Hair
$16.99
jumbo shrimp sauteed with mushrooms tomatoes and green onions, smothered in a cajun cream sauce served over angel hair pasta.
'Cedar Plank' Salmon
$16.99
fresh norwegian salmon, roasted and served with sauteed fresh vegetables and wild rice.
Miner's Chicken
$13.99
char-grilled, barbeque glazed chicken breast topped with two crisp onion rings. served with whipped potatoes and cole slaw.
O'Toole's Baby Back Ribs
$24.99
our ribs are dry rubbed and marinated for over 24 hours then slow cooked. lightly brushed with our signature bbq sauce and finished on the flame grill. full rack & half rack.
Sausage Linguine
$16.99
diced smoked sausage sauteed with bell peppers and onions in a white wine sauce.
Snow Crab Legs
how hearty is your appetite? our whole steamed crab legs are served by the pound with drawn butter and sauteed fresh vegetables. per pound.
Sides
Colossal Onion Rings
$4.99
Whipped Potatoes
$4.99
Boardwalk French Fries
$4.99
Wild Rice
$4.99
Mac-N-Cheese
$4.99
Signature Entrees
'Cedar Plank' Salmon
$16.99
fresh norwegian salmon, roasted and served with sauteed fresh vegetables and wild rice.
'Lake Erie' Fish & Chips
$17.99
an ohio fisherman's delight with a twist, deep fried golden brown served with boardwalk fries, house made coleslaw and remoulade sauce.
12 Oz. New York Strip
$23.99
all of our char-grilled selections are cooked to order and topped with our house garlic butter. served with redskin smashed potatoes.
14 Oz. Boneless Ribeye
$25.99
all of our char-grilled selections are cooked to order and topped with our house garlic butter. served with redskin smashed potatoes.
16 Oz. Bone-In Ribeye
$28.99
all of our char-grilled selections are cooked to order and topped with our house garlic butter. served with redskin smashed potatoes.
6 Oz. Filet Mignon
$22.99
all of our char-grilled selections are cooked to order and topped with our house garlic butter. served with redskin smashed potatoes.
8 Oz. Sirloin
$21.99
all of our char-grilled selections are cooked to order and topped with our house garlic butter. served with redskin smashed potatoes.
Alaskan King Crab Legs
$24.99
a full pound of whole steamed crab legs with drawn butter and sauteed fresh vegetables.
Cajun Shrimp & Angel Hair
$16.99
jumbo shrimp smothered in a cajun cream sauce served over angel hair pasta.
Chilean Sea Bass
$20.99
pan-seared and oven baked, served with sauteed fresh vegetables, wild rice and finished with a savory lemon butter sauce.
Lamb Porterhouse
$22.99
all of our char-grilled selections are cooked to order and topped with our house garlic butter. served with redskin smashed potatoes.
Miner's Chicken
$13.99
char-grilled, barbeque glazed chicken breast topped with two crisp onion rings. served with whipped potatoes and coleslaw.
O'Toole's Baby Back Ribs
$23.99
our ribs are dry rubbed and marinated for over 24 hours then slow cooked. lightly brushed with our signature b.b.q sauce and finished on the flame grill. served with boardwalk french fries and a side of b.b.q sauce. (full rack, half rack).
Sausage Linguine
$16.99
diced, smoked sausage sauteed with bell peppers and onions in a white wine sauce.
Slow Roasted Prime Rib
$24.99
each morning we season our slow roasted usda prime 'prime rib' with michael o'toole's secret spice rub, we then slow roast it until it becomes the tenderest prime rib you have ever tasted. served with house made redskin smashed potatoes and au jus.
Stuffed Chicken Breast
$15.99
a whole roasted airline chicken breast stuffed with prosciutto and gorgonzola cheese and served with sauteed fresh vegetables and wild rice.
Desserts
Blueberry Bread Pudding
$5.99
an old fashioned, delicious comfort dessert! buttery croissants steeped in vanilla custard, stuffed with fresh blueberries and chocolate chips. served with vanilla anglaise.
Chocolate Molten Cake
$5.99
warm chocolate cake with a creamy, molten center served with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream on top. we add chocolate sauce and berries to finish this delicious dessert.
Cinnamon Peach Cobbler
$5.99
sweet georgia peaches cooked with cinnamon, nutmeg and a hint of vanilla, topped with stuessal and baked to a golden brown.
New York Cheesecake
$5.99
traditional new york style cheesecake served with fresh berries, whipped cream and vanilla anglaise.