Pick a Bagel Cafe & Catering at 785 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10065
Pick a Bagel Cafe & Catering Menu in New York
Hot Breakfast
Egg Sandwich
$4.75
Egg Platter
$7.25
Served with Home-Fries or Lettuce & Tomato and Your Choice of Bagel or Bread.
Veggie Omelette
$9.95
Made with broccoli, mushrooms & bell peppers. Served with home fried or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
Greek Omelette
$9.95
Made with Feta cheese, Kalamata olives & Beef Stake tomatoes. Served with home fries or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
Western Omelette
$9.95
Spanish Omelette
$9.95
Made with Bermuda Onions, Bell Peppers & Diced Tomatoes. Served with home fries or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
3 Cheese Omeeltte
$9.95
Made with sharp Vermont cheddar, Jarlsberg Swiss Cheese & American Cheese. Served with home fries or lettuce and tomatoes Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
The New Yorker
$12.95
Made with Nova Scotia Salmon,Eggs & Bermuda Onions served with Home Fries or Lettuce & Tomato and Your Choice of Bagel or Bread.
2 Cinnamon Pancakes
$7.75
2 Eggs & 2 Pancakes
$9.75
One of Each
$7.95
One Egg, One Pancake, One Sausage Patty, One Bacon Strip.
Two of Each
$10.5
2 Eggs, 2 Pancakes, 2 Sausage Patties, 2 Bacon Strips.
Light Healthy Choices
Oatmeal
$5.75
Fruit Salad
$5.95
Yogurt Parfait
$5.75
Banana
$1
Orange
$1.75
Apple
$1.5
Muffins & Pastries
Regular Muffins
$3.75
Plain Croissant
$3.75
Filled Croissant
$3.95
Danish
$3.95
Jumbo Cookie
$3.95
Loaf Cake
$3
Cupcake
$3.95
Loaf Cake
$4
Challah Bread
$6.5
Cream Cheese Spreads on a Bagel
Bagel with Butter
$2.95
Peanut Butter Sandwich
$4.25
Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.25
Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Strawberry Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Sun Dried Tomato Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Olive Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Lox Spread Cream Cheese Sandwich
$6.5
Low-Fat Lox Spread Cream Cheese Sandwich
$6.5
Tofu Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Bagels
One Bagel
$1.5
New York Baker's Dozen Bagels
$18
Salad Sandwiches
Farmer's Choice Egg Salad Sandwich
$8.5
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$9.75
Low-Fat Chicken Salad Sandwich
$9.75
Home-Style Tuna Salad Sandwich
$9.75
Low-Fat Tuna Salad Sandwich
$9.75
Shrimp Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Salad Platters
Farmer's Choice Egg Salad Platter
$10.5
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Chicken Salad Platter
$11.75
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Low-Fat Chicken Salad Platter
$11.75
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Home-Style Tuna Salad Platter
$11.75
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Low-Fat Tuna Salad Platter
$11.75
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Vegetarian Tuna
$11.75
No mayo.
Jumbo Shrimp Salad Platter
$12.95
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucumbers, Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce.
Smoked Fish & Appetizing
Smoked Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich
$12.95
Smoked Nova Scotia Salmon Platter
$15.95
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucumbers, Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce.
Smoked Jumbo White Fish Sandwich
$12.25
Smoked Jumbo White Fish Platter
$15.25
Kippered Salmon Sandwich
$12.25
Kippered Salmon Platter
$15.25
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich
$11.45
Baked Salmon Salad Platter
$14.45
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucumbers, Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce.
Pastrami Nova Sandwich
$12.95
Smoked White Fish Salad Sandwich
$11.45
Smoked White Fish Salad Platter
$14.45
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucumbers, Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce.
Pastrami Nova Platter
$15.95
Smoked Fish Combination Platter
$29.95
Includes all 4 of the above.
Deli Meat Sandwiches
BLT Sandwich
$7.65
Black Forest Ham Sandwich
$9.5
Genoa Salami Sandwich
$7.95
Oven Roasted Turkey Breast Sandwich
$9.5
Honey Glazed Turkey Sandwich
$9.5
Smoked Turkey Breast Sandwich
$7.95
Roast Beef Sandwich
$7.95
Pastrami Sandwich
$11.25
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
$7.95
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$9.5
Slices Cheese Sandwiches
American Cheese Sandwich
$7.25
Muenster Cheese Sandwich
$7.25
Cheddar Cheese Sandwich
$7.25
Swiss Cheese Sandwich
$7.25
Pepper Jack Cheese Sandwich
$7.25
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese Sandwich
$7.25
Provolone Cheese Sandwich
$5.5
Hearty Soups
Home-Made Chicken Noodle Soup
$6.5
Vegetarian Split Pea Soup
$6.5
Supreme Sandwiches
Supreme Pastrami
$13.25
Hot pastrami, Melted Swiss cheese, Spicy Mustard & Garlic Aioli . (Recommended on Seeded Rye)
Supreme Reuben
$12.25
Hot corned beef, Melted Muenster cheese, Sauerkraut, Spicy golden mustard. (recommended on Seeded Rye)
Supreme Turkey Club
$11.95
Smoked turkey, Indiana bacon, Romaine lettuce, Plum tomatoes, & Light mayonnaise. (Recommended on Country Sour Dough)
Supreme Tuscan Turkey
$11.95
Oven roasted turkey, Artichoke, Tomato, Mixed baby greens, & Artichoke pesto. (Recommended on Ciabatta Square)
Supreme Pesto Chicken
$11.95
Grilled chicken, Roasted red peppers, Melted fresh mozzarella, & Basil Pesto Aioli. (Recommended on Ciabatta)
Supreme Ham & Cheese
$11.95
Black forest ham, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, Plum tomatoes, Romaine lettuce & Garlic Aioli. (Recommended on Country Sour Dough)
Supreme Grilled Chicken Club
$11.95
Grilled chicken, Smoked Bacon, Romaine lettuce, Plum tomatoes, & Creamy herbed Mayonnaise. (Recommended on Rustic Square)
Supreme Cali Turkey Special
$11.95
Smoked turkey, Avocado, Swiss cheese, Crispy bacon, Romaine lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Drizzled EVOO. (Recommended On Plain Bagel)
Supreme Chicken Salad
$11.95
Oven roasted chicken breast, Crispy bacon, Swiss cheese, Mixed baby greens, & Light mayonnaise. (Recommended on Rustic Square)
Supreme Hell's Kitchen
$11.95
Black forest ham, Honey glazed turkey, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, Vermont cheddar cheese, Romaine lettuce & Honey Dijon spread. (Recommended on Sesame Bagel)
Supreme Tuna Melt
$11.95
Home-style Tuna Salad, Melted Vermont Cheddar, Mixed Baby Greens, & Plum Tomato. (Recommended on Hearty Multi-Grain Bread)
Supreme Veggie Lover
$11.95
Portobello mushrooms, Avocado, Sprouts, Plum tomatoes, Fresh Goat cheese & Creamy Balsamic Vinaigrette. (Recommended on Plain Bagel)
Supreme Fresh Mozzarella
$11.95
Fresh Made Mozzarella, Plum Tomatoes, Roasted Red Peppers & Basil Pesto Spread. (Recommended on Rustic Square)
Supreme Russian
$8.95
Hot roast beef, Vermont cheddar, Caramelized onions, Romaine lettuce, Beefsteak tomatoes & Russian dressing. (Recommended on a Sesame Bagel)
Italian Combo
$8.95
Hard salami, Black Forest Ham, Provolone cheese, Romaine lettuce , Beefsteak tomatoes, Artichoke Pesto & EVOO. (Recommended on Rustic Square)
Farmer's Egg Salad
$8.95
Home-made Egg Salad, Romaine Lettuce, Plum Tomatoes, Kosher Salt, & Cracked Black Pepper. (Recommended on a Everything Bagel)
Spreads By The Lb.
Butter
$3
Peanut Butter
$3.75
Plain Cream Cheese
$3.5
Scallion Cream Cheese
$4.25
Strawberry Cream Cheese
$4.25
Sun Dried Tomato Cream Cheese
$4.25
Vegetable Cream Cheese
$4.25
Walnut & Raisin Cream Cheese
$4.25
Olive Cream Cheese
$4.25
Low-Fat Cream Cheese
$4.25
Fat-Free Cream Cheese
$3.75
Fat-Free Vegetable Cream Cheese
$4.25
Tofu Cream Cheese
$4.25
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese
$4.25
Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese
$4.25
Lox Cream Cheese
$5.25
Low-Fat Lox Cream Cheese
$5.25
Salads By The Lb.
Egg Salad
$4.5
Chicken Salad
$5.95
Low Fat Chicken Salad
$5.95
Home-Style Tuna Salad
$5.95
Vegetarian Tuna Salad
$5.95
Low-Fat Tuna Salad
$5.95
Meats By The Lb.
Black Forest Ham
$6.5
Smoked Turkey Breast
$6.5
Oven Gold Turkey Breast
$6.5
Honey Glazed Turkey
$6.5
Grilled Chicken
$6.5
Pastrami
$7.95
Corned Beef
$6.5
Bologna
$5.5
Genoa Salami
$5.5
Roast Beef
$5.5
Virginia Ham
$5.5
Smoked Fish By The Lb.
Nova Scotia Smoked Salmon
$14.25
Smoked Jumbo White Fish
$10
Kippered Salmon
$10.5
Baked Salmon Salad
$9
Smoked White Fish Salad
$9
Jumbo Shrimp Salad
$9
Pastrami Nova
$13.95
Cheese By The Lb.
American Cheese
$5.25
Muenster Cheese
$5.25
Cheddar Cheese
$5.25
Swiss Cheese
$5.25
Pepper Jack Cheese
$5.25
Fresh Mozzarella
$5.25
Alpine Lace Swiss Cheese
$5.25
Provolone Cheese
$5.25
Extra Sides
Side of Home Fries
$3.75
Side of Bacon
$3.5
Side of Sausage
$3.5
Side of Turkey Bacon
$3.5
Side of Tomato
$2.5
Side of Cucumber
$2.5
Side of Red Onion
$1.75
Side of Sour Pickle (1/2 size)
$1
Beverages
Hot Coffee
$2.5
Hot Tea
Hot Chocolate
$3.75
Espresso
$3.75
Cappuccino
$3.25
Latte
$3.75
Americano
$3.5
Iced Coffee
$3
Iced Tea
Iced Espresso
$3.75
Iced Cappuccino
$4.25
Iced Latte
$4.25
Can Soda
$2.25
Tropicana
$3
Fresh Squeezed Juice
$4.95
Snapple
$2.95
Gatorade
$2.95
Naked Juices
$5.25
NesQuick
$3.25
Poland Springs Water
$2.5
Sparkling Ice ***NEW***
$1.5
Can Soda
$1.35
All Natural Smoothie Bar
Small Smoothie
$6.5
Large Smoothie
$7.5
Catering - Beverages
Catering Coffee (Per Person)
$2.25
10 person minimum. Quality fresh-brewed La Colombe coffee including milk and sweeteners.
Catering Coffee To-Go Box
$22
96 oz. quality fresh-brewed La Colombe coffee including milk and sweeteners.
Catering Tea (Per Person)
$2.25
10 person minimum. Assortment of Harney & Sons teas with milk, sweeteners, and lemon wedges.
Catering Fresh-Squeezed OJ (Per Person)
$4.25
10 Person Minimum.
Catering - Breakfast
Catering - The Traditional Breakfast
$185
Serves 10. Eastern Nova Scotia salmon, whitefish centerpiece, and baked salmon. Includes choice of cream cheese and assorted bagels.
Catering - Bagels & Lox
$165
Serves 10. Freshly sliced Eastern Nova Scotia salmon. Includes choices of cream cheese and assorted bagels.
Catering - Bagels & Schmears (Per Person)
$6.99
10 Person Minimum. Includes your choice of three house made cream cheeses, and assorted hand rolled, freshly baked bagels.
Catering - Hot Station (Per Person)
$9.5
10 Person Minimum. Scrambled eggs & home fries.
Catering - Homemade Challah French Toast (Per Person)
$9.5
10 Person Minimum. Served with strawberries and bananas.
Catering - Homemade Pancakes (Per Person)
$9.5
10 Person Minimum. Served with strawberries and bananas.
Catering - Continental Breakfast (Per Person)
$9.95
10 Person Minimum. Your choice of 3 homemade cream cheeses. Comes with mini assorted danishes, house made muffins, fresh squeezed O.J., fresh brewed La Colombe coffee and an assortment of our hand rolled, freshly baked bagels.
Catering - Executive Breakfast (Per Person)
$12.5
10 person minimum. Your choice of 3 homemade cream cheeses with sliced beefsteak tomatoes, house-made muffins, seasonal fruit bowl, fresh squeezed orange juice, fresh-brewed La Colombe coffee, and assorted bagels.
Pastry Basket (Per Person)
$4.95
10 person minimum. Assorted fresh-baked muffins and danishes.
Seasonal Fruit Platter (Per Person)
$4.95
10 Person Minimum.
Yogurt & Granola Bowl (Per Person)
$5.5
10 Person Minimum. With choice of yogurt.
Catering - Lunch Sandwiches
Signature Sandwiches Platter (Per Person)
$12.5
10 person minimum. Assortment of our signature sandwich on your choice of bagels, artisanal breads, or wraps. Includes pickles and choice of in-house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Signature Sandwich Platter with Beverages & Chips (Per Person)
$14.5
10 person minimum. Assortment of our signature sandwiches on your choice of bagels, artisanal breads, or wraps. Includes pickles and choice of in-house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Deli Sandwich Platter (Per Person)
$11.95
10 person minimum. Selection of meats and cheeses on bagels, artisanal breads, or wraps. Served with beefsteak tomatoes and romaine. Includes pickles and choice of in-house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Deli Sandwich Platter with Beverages & Chips (Per Person)
$13.95
10 person minimum. Selection of meats and cheeses on bagels, artisanal breads, or wraps. Served with beefsteak tomatoes and romaine. Includes pickles and choice of in-house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Cold Cut Platter (Per Person)
$11.95
10 person minimum. Choice of 3 meats, 3 cheeses, assorted bagels, breads, and wraps, beefsteak tomatoes, and romaine. Includes pickles and choice of in-house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Cold Cut Platter with Beverages & Drinks (Per Person)
$13.95
10 person minimum. Choice of 3 meats, 3 cheeses, assorted bagels, breads, and wraps, beefsteak tomatoes, and romaine. Includes pickles and choice of in-house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Deli Salads Platter (Per Person)
$10.95
10 person minimum. Your choice of 3 freshly prepared homemade salads, served with an assortment of bagels, artisanal breads, and wraps. Includes beefsteak tomatoes and romaine.
Deli Salads Platter with Beverages & Chips (Per Person)
$12.95
10 person minimum. Your choice of 3 freshly prepared homemade salads, served with an assortment of bagels, artisanal breads, and wraps. Includes beefsteak tomatoes and romaine.
Signature Sandwich Boxed Lunch (Per Person)
$15
10 person minimum. Your choice of sandwich with pickle, house-made coleslaw, traditional black and white cookie, and choice of can of soda or bottled water.
Catering - Lunch Salads
Caesar Salad (Per Person)
$5.75
10 person minimum. Romaine, shaved Parmesan, cherry tomato, and croutons.
Mediterranean Salad (Per Person)
$5.75
10 person minimum. Mesclun, tomatoes, feta, olives, red onion, bell peppers, croutons, cucumbers, and parsley.
Cobb Salad (Per Person)
$6.25
10 person minimum. Iceberg and romaine, avocado, applewood smoked bacon, chopped egg, crumbled blue cheese, and chopped tomatoes.
Asian Sesame Salad (Per Person)
$7.75
10 person minimum. Mixed baby greens with grilled chicken, edamame, mandarin oranges, corn, shredded carrots, Bermuda onion, sliced almonds, and Asian sesame ginger dressing.
Garden Salad (Per Person)
$4.95
10 person minimum. Mesclun, sliced red onion, beefsteak tomatoes, olives, croutons, and cucumber.
Sophia Salad (Per Person)
$5.95
10 person minimum. Mesclun greens, candied walnut, oranges, and feta, served with vinaigrette dressing.
Kale Salad (Per Person)
$5.95
10 person minimum. Kale, cranberry, candied walnut, oranges, and feta, served with vinaigrette dressing.
Salad Boxed Lunch (Per Person)
$12.95
10 person minimum. Your choice of individually boxed salad with kettle chips, traditional black and white cookie, plus bottled water or soda.
Catering - Cold Cuts, Cheese, Deli Salads
Catering Pastrami
$10.5
Catering Honey Roasted Turkey
$10.5
Catering Smoked Turkey
$10.5
Catering Black Forest Ham
$10.5
Catering Grilled Chicken Cutlet
$10.5
Catering American Cheese
$7.5
Catering Muenster Cheese
$7.5
Catering Swiss Cheese
$7.5
Catering Fresh Mozzarella Cheese
$7.5
Catering Cheddar Cheese
$7.5
Catering Provolone
$7.5
Catering Pepper Jack
$7.5
Catering Tuna Salad
$9.5
Catering Low-Fat Tuna Salad
$9.5
Catering Whitefish Salad
$9.5
Catering Baked Salmon Salad
$9.5
Catering Egg Salad
$9.5
Catering Chicken Salad
$9.5
Catering - Sides
Pasta Primavera (Per Person)
$5
10 Person Minimum.
Pesto Tortellini (Per Person)
$5
10 Person Minimum.
Sun-Dried Tomato (Per Person)
$5
10 Person Minimum.
Olive Penne (Per Person)
$5
10 Person Minimum.
House-Made Coleslaw (Per Platter)
$15
Serves 10.
Bucket of Pickles (Per Person)
$2.5
10 Person Minimum.
Catering - Sweets & Cheeses
Catering Dessert Platter (Per Person)
$6.5
10 person minimum. A freshly baked assortment of muffins, brownies, cakes, and cookies, garnished and plattered.
Classic Cheese Board (Per Person)
$5.95
10 Person Minimum. An assortment of imported and domestic cheeses, garnished with seasonal fresh fruits. Gourmet cracker selections also included.
Crudite Platter (Per Person)
$4.95
10 Person Minimum.