Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels Menu with Prices

Egg Sandwich

$5.5

2 scrambled eggs sandwich.

Egg and Cheese Sandwich

$6

2 scrambled eggs sandwich with cheese.

Bacon and Egg Sandwich

$6

2 scrambled eggs and bacon sandwich.

Sausage and Egg Sandwich

$6

2 scrambled eggs with sausage sandwich.

Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

$7

2 scrambled eggs with bacon and cheese sandwich.

Ham and Egg Sandwich

$6

2 scrambled eggs with Forest Pork Store cooked ham sandwich.

Grilled Ham and Cheese Sandwich

$6

Grilled Forest Pork Store cooked ham and cheese sandwich.

Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

$7

2 scrambled eggs with Forest Pork Store cooked ham and cheese sandwich.

Sausage, Egg and Cheese

$7

2 scrambled eggs, sausage, and cheese sandwich.

Jersey Pork Roll, Egg and Cheese Sandwich

$8.5

2 scrambled eggs, Taylor ham, and cheese sandwich.

Scrapple, Egg and Cheddar Sandwich

$9.5

2 over easy eggs, scrapple, cheddar with real NYS maple syrup on an onion roll.

Cream Cheese and Bacon Sandwich

$6

Grilled Cheese Sandwich on Plain Rye

$5.5

Smoked Whitefish Salad Sandwich

$13

Shelsky's of Brooklyn famous whitefish salad made with Door County, Wisconsin smoked whitefish, cucumbers, and celery sandwich.

Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich

$13

Shelsky's of Brooklyn rich and smooth baked salmon salad.

Seriously Great Tuna Salad Sandwich

$11.5

Shelsky's of Brooklyn seriously great tuna salad sandwich.

Chopped Herring Sandwich

$10.5

Shelsky's of Brooklyn chopped pickled herring.

Chopped Liver Sandwich

$13

Shelsky's of Brooklyn homemade chopped chicken liver mixed with fried onions, hard-boiled eggs and luscious amounts of schmaltz.

Egg Salad Sandwich

$9.5

Shelsky's of Brooklyn egg salad with cornichons (French gherkin pickles).

Chicken Salad Sandwich

$11

Shelsky's of Brooklyn chicken salad with Giannone chickens with pecans, grapes, and celery sandwich.

Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich

$5

Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich

$5.5

Lox Cream Cheese Sandwich

$7

Cream cheese mixed with ground Nova smoked salmon.

Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich

$7

Cream cheese mixed with bell peppers, scallions, and garlic.

Jalapeno Cream Cheese Sandwich

$5.5

Cream cheese mixed with spicy jalapenos.

Sichuan Spicy Chili Crisp Cream Cheese Sandwich

$6

Cream cheese mixed with spicy chili crisp (ground dried chilies, soy nuts, fried onions, Sichuan peppercorns, MSG).

Goat Cream Cheese Sandwich

$7.5

Tofu Cream Cheese Sandwich

$6

Ben's Cheese Planet tofu cream cheese.

Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich

$6.5

Ben's Cheese Planet tofu cream cheese with scallions.

Ben's Cream Cheese Sandwich

$7

Ben's cheese planet all-natural plain cream cheese sandwich.

Butter Sandwich

$3

Butter and Jelly Sandwich

$3.5

Butter and choice of raspberry or apricot fruit preserves on choice of bread.

Cream Cheese and Jelly Sandwich

$5.5

Cream cheese and choice of raspberry or apricot fruit preserves on bread.

Member Of The Tribe Sandwich

$13.5

Hand-sliced Nova smoked salmon with cream cheese sandwich (aka bagel with lox).

Brooklyn Native Sandwich

$15.5

Our famous whitefish salad made with Door County, Wisconsin whitefish, hand-sliced Nova smoked salmon, chopped herring salad, and sour pickles sandwich.

The Great Gatsby Sandwich

$15.5

Hand-sliced pastrami-smoked salmon, horseradish cream cheese, honey mustard, and sliced red onions on caraway-seeded rye.

The Newhouse Sandwich

$15.5

Hand-sliced wild Alaskan sable, scallion cream cheese, and tomato on a toasted onion bialy.

The Turboff Sandwich

$16

Baked salmon salad with hand-sliced Nova smoked salmon, horseradish cream cheese, tomatoes, red onions, capers and lemon juice on a toasted onion bialy.

The Clementine Sandwich

$15

House-cured gravlax with butter, red onion, tomato, capers and lemon juice on a toasted bialy.

Roast Beef Sandwich

$11.5

Roast Turkey Sandwich

$11.5

Homemade roasted Dipaola Farm turkey sandwich.

Cooked Ham Sandwich

$8

Black Forest Ham Sandwich

$9

Virginia Ham Sandwich

$9

Sliced Liverwurst Sandwich

$7

Bologna Sandwich

$7

Genoa Salami

$9

Roast Turkey

$8

Salsalito Turkey

$8

Chopped Cheese Sandwich

$9

Chopped up hamburgers with melted American cheese, grilled onions, raw onions, tomatoes, lettuce, mayo, and ketchup pressed on a seeded hero.

Roast Beef on an Onion Roll Sandwich

$16

Homemade roast beef, butter, Dijon mustard, and crispy fried onions on an onion roll.

Shelsky's Roast Turkey Sandwich

$16.5

Homemade roasted Dipaola turkey farm turkey, coleslaw, Swiss, and Russian dressing on rye or pumpernickel.

Shelsky's Hot Pastrami Sandwich

$21

Shelsky's of Brooklyn delicatessen hot pastrami, sliced thin, with deli mustard on rye.

Shelsky's Corned Beef Sandwich

$22

Shelsky's of Brooklyn delicatessen hot corned beef with deli mustard on rye.

Shelsky's Reuben Sandwich

$23

Shelsky's of Brooklyn delicatessen hot corned beef, Riesling-braised sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing pressed on plain rye.

Lewis' Knish Bomb Sandwich

$19

Shelsky's of Brooklyn delicatessen hot pastramI, Riesling-braised sauerkraut, and deli mustard served on a fried Coney Island-style knish.

Shelsky's Hot Pastrami Sandwich

$23

Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Delicatessen hot pastrami, sliced thinly with deli mustard on Orwasher's rye

Plain Bagel

$1.6

3-day fermented, sourdough plain bagels, dense, chewy, just the right size.

Sesame Bagels

$1.6

Our plain bagels coated with all natural sesame seeds and a hint of pretzel salt.

Poppy Bagel

$1.6

Our plain bagels coated with poppy seeds.

Onion Bagel

$1.6

Our plain bagels coated with dried onions.

Garlic Bagel

$1.6

Our plain bagels coated with crunchy garlic.

Cracked Pepper and Salt Bagel

$1.6

A bagel au poivre.

Sichuan Peppercorn Black Sesame Bagel

$1.6

Our plain bagels with the numbing zing of imported single plantation Sichuan peppercorns.

Salt Bagel

$1.6

Our plain bagels with pretzel salt.

Everything Bagel

$1.6

Our plain bagels coated with sesame, poppy, onion, garlic, and pretzel salt.

Whole Wheat Bagels

$1.6

A whole wheat bagel made whole wheat flour and a mash of rolled and steel cut oats, hemp seed, flax seed and wheat germ topped with a germ mixture.

Whole Wheat Everything Bagel

$1.6

Our stunning whole wheat bagels topped with our everything topping.

Pumpernickel Bagel

$1.6

A complex chewy bagel with rye flour, coffee, and cocoa powder.

Egg Bagel

$1.6

Not your average egg bagel? made with egg yolks, turmeric, annatto, and Indian sulfur salt.

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel

$1.6

Not as sweet as is often the case, our cinnamon raisin bagels are pretty perfect.

Onion Bialy

$1.6

The lighter Polish-Jewish, not boiled cousin of the bagel with slow-cooked onion jam.

Garlic Bialy

$1.6

The lighter Polish-Jewish, not boiled cousin of the bagel with roasted garlic confit, poppy seeds, and pretzel salt.

Mixed Dozen

$20

Choice of any mixture of bagels and/or bialys. If you would like multiples of a certain flavor and/or combination, please indicate the quantity of each in the Special Instructions.

Gluten Free Plain Bagel

$12

The great knead gluten free bagels, pack of 4, comes frozen.

4 Pack Gluten Free Everything Bagels

$12

The great knead gluten free bagels, pack of 4, comes frozen.

Onion Roll

$1.6

Orwasher's bakery famous onion pockets with onion inside and out, a NYC classic.

Kaiser Roll

$1.6

Mazzola bakery kaiser rolls, simple, classic.

Seeded Hero Roll

$2.5

Classic seeded hero roll from Mazzola bakery.

Lard Bread

$7

Mazzola bakery lard bread, a hero loaf with salamI, cheese, and lots of black pepper? a Carroll Gardens Italian classic.

1/2 lb. Bologna

$7

Forest Pork Store bologna is mild and silky.

1/2 lb. Cooked Ham

$7

Forest Pork Store ham is cooked and has a clean ham flavor.

1/2 lb. Black Forest Ham

$8

Forest Pork Store black forest ham is a little dryer, firmer, and smokier than the cooked ham.

1/2 lb. Westphalian Ham

$8

Forest Pork Store Westphalian ham is their smokiest. It is really terrific served with butter.

1/2 lb. Braunschweiger

$7

Forest Pork Store's Braunschweiger liverwurst is a tender, sliceable liverwurst? it's a personal favorite of ours.

1/2 lb. Cervelatwurst

$8

Forest Pork Store cervelat is a hard salami that is perfect served on a roll with some butter.

1/2 lb. Roast Beef

$14.5

We roast our beef in-house at Shelsky's of Brooklyn on Court Street. It is rare to medium rare and perfectly brined.

1/2 lb. Turkey

$14.5

We brine Dipaola Turkey Farm breasts and thighs for 3 days, tie them into roasts and roast them slowly. No emulsified turkey product here!

1/2 lb. Corned Beef

$16

Our corned beef is cured for more than a week with a balanced blend of spices for that classic Brooklyn flavor. We then steam it until tender it's super tender.

1/2 lb. Pastrami

$16

Our pastrami is cut from the navel, making it super moist. Cured for more than a week, then rubbed and smoked, we steam it until it is super tender!

1/2 lb. Plain Cream Cheese

$5.5

Double-whipped plain cream cheese.

1/2 lb. Scallion Cream Cheese

$6

Double-whipped cream cheese with scallions.

1/2 lb. Lox Cream Cheese

$9.25

Double-whipped cream cheese mixed with ground Nova smoked salmon.

1/2 lb. Vegetable Cream Cheese

$8.5

Double-whipped cream cheese with bell peppers, scallions, and garlic.

1/2 lb. Horseradish Cream Cheese

$8.5

Double-whipped cream cheese with freshly grated horseradish root.

1/2 lb. Jalapeno Cream Cheese

$6

Double-whipped cream cheese with spicy jalapenos. (It is actually spicy.)

1/2 lb. Sichuan Chili Crisp Cream Cheese

$7

Double-whipped cream cheese with spicy chilI crisp (Ground dried chilies, soy nuts, fried onions, Sichuan peppercorns, and MSG).

1/2 lb. Ben's All Natural Cream Cheese

$6.5

Ben's Cheese Planet all-natural plain cream cheese is extra creamy and luxurious.

1/2 lb. Goat Cream Cheese

$9

Creamy goat cream cheese with assertive goaty-ness.

1/2 lb. Tofu Cream Cheese

$8

Ben's Cheese Planet's tofu cream cheese.

1/2 lb. Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese

$8.5

Ben's Cheese Planet's tofuc ream cheese with scallions mixed in.

16 oz. Cup Cold Brew Ashlawn Farm Coffee

$4.5

12 oz. Fresh Squeezed Juice

$4

16.9 oz. Poland Spring Water

$1.5

Canada Dry Seltzer

$1.5

Canned Soda

$1.5

Dr. Browns Canned Soda

$1.75

Yoo-Hoo Can

$1.75

Harmless Harvest Coconut Water

$5

Tropicana Orange Juice 14 oz. Carton

$3.25

Hint Water

$3.25

Spindrift Sparkling Water 16 oz. Can

$3.5

Drip Coffee

$2.5

Ashlawn Farm's Deterra Villa Borghese coffee rich and bold.

Darjeeling Tea

$2.5

Palais des Thes Margaret's Hope Darjeeling is a classic morning black tea.

Earl Grey Tea

$2.5

Palais des Thes Margaret's Blue of London has floral notes and citrusy bergamot.

Mint Green Tea

$2.5

Palais des Thes green tea with mint is mild and soul-affirming.

Genmaicha Green Tea

$2.5

Palais des Thes Genmaicha is a mild Japanese green tea with toasted rice.

Rooibos

$2.5

Palais des Thes Rooibos red tea has no caffeine and has notes of sweet tobacco and vanilla.