Sugar Box NYC Menu with Prices

Chocolate Brownie Fudge Bar

$4.95

Fudge brownie with shaved dark chocolate as topping.

Caramel Nut Bar

$4.95

Wheats, eggs, milk, peanuts and soy. Rich squares with caramel & chocolate chip.

Oreo Cookie Bar

$4.95

Classic Oreo cookies bar. Milk, eggs, wheat and soy.

Raspberry Linzar Bar

$4

Raspberry jam on a brownie bar. Milk, eggs, wheat & soy.

Lemon Bar

$4.95

Kosher. Lemon jam.

Milk Cult Vegan Avocado Ice Cream Sandwich

$4.5

Milk Cult. Vegan. Coconut milk. Hand made. Avocado ice cream with chocolate wafer.

Milk Cult Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich

$4.5

Milk Cult. Hand made. Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chip cookie sandwich.

Macaron Ice Cream Cookies & Cream !!new!!

$5.95

Rich pieces of chocolate cookies immersed in creamy vanilla ice cream, topped with chocolate crumbles. Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs, Wheat, Soy

Italian Bomba Gelato Cannoball Ice Cream Sandwich

$5.95

A scoop of classic vanilla and chocolate gelato separated by a cherry and sliced almonds covered in cinnamon, finished with a chocolate coating. Individual servings.

Hazelnut Truffle Bomba Ice Cream Sandwich

$5.95

Hazelnuts semifreddo ice cream with a liquid chocolate core, coated with praline hazelnuts and crushed meringue. Individual serving.

Crunchy Almond Semifreddo

$5.95

Made with whipped cream. A base of sponge cake topped with hazelnut semifreddo with a heart of chocolate, all covered with caramelized almonds.

Chocolate Truffle Bomba

$5.95

Zabaione cream center, surrounded by chocolate gelato and caramelized hazelnuts, topped with cocoa powder

Exotic Bomba Ice Cream Sandwich

$5.95

Mango, passion fruit and raspberry sorbetto, all covered in white chocolate and drizzled with chocolate. Individual serving.

Jeni's Dark Chocolate Truffle (new)

$5.95

Street treats. Vegan. Dairy free. Coconut cream. 3.6 0z per cup. Pre Packed. Individual serving

Jeni's Lemon Buttermilk Yogurt frozen (new)

$5.95

Fresh lemon juice, cultured buttermilk, organic yogurt and cream. 3.6 oz cup. Pre packed. Individual serving.

Jeni's Salted Peanut Butter Chocolate Flakes (new)

$5.95

Salted ground roasted peanuts with grass grazed Ohio milk and crunchy, dark chocolate flakes. 3.6 oz cups. Pre packed. Individual serving.

Fly Fishing Fudge Shake (new)

$9

vanilla ice cream, m&m, cookie dough, chocolate chips, fudge ripples. Gifford's

Muddy Boots Shake (new)

$9

Vanilla ice cream, caramel ripples, brownie bits

Cotton Candy ice cream shake (new)

$9

Pink and blue cotton candy flavor. PBsT free

Chocolate Lover's Chocolate Shake

$9

Gifford's rich chocolate ice cream with chocolate cake crunch, chocolate truffles and fudge ripples.

Cake Batter Shake

$9

Yellow cake batter ice cream with chocolate frosting and shortcake chunks.

Double Cookies and Cream Shake

$9

Gifford's cookies in cream in vanilla ice cream.

Green Mint Chip Shake

$9

Green Mint Chip ice cream. Gifford's.

Cookie Dough Cake Batter Shake

$9

Gifford's vanilla ice cream with chocolate chips and cookie dough.

Sea Salt Caramel Truffle Shake

$9

Gifford's vanilla ice cream sea salt caramel truffle.

Jeni's Texas Sheet Cake Non Dairy Frozen Dessert (new)

$16.95

Decadent chocolate cake crumbles, bittersweet fudge, and palate-gripping cocoa. Big, bold, beautiful.

Jeni's Dark Chocolate Truffle (new)

$16.95

Dairy-free and vegan

Van Leeuwen Oat Milk Brown Sugar Chunk (new)

$13

creamy oat milk muscovado brown sugar ice cream with brownies, cookie dough and crunchy candied oat clusters

Van Leeuwen Oat Milk Mocha Latte (new)

$13

Oatmilk coffee ice cream, housemade fudge swirls

Van Leeuwan Vegan Oatmilk Chocolate Cookie Dough Chunk (new)

$13

Vegan made with Oatmilk, chocolate cookie dough,cruchy honecombe candy

Van Leeuwan Vegan Oatmilk Caramel Cookie (new)

$13

Vegan, Gluten Free made with creamy Oatmilk base, gluten free oatmilk cookie and housemade caramel swirl

Van Leeuwen Cookie Crumble Strawberry Jam Vegan (new)

$13

gluten free oat cookies, strawberry jam in creamy vegan base

Van Leeuwen Vegan Cookies & Cream Caramel Swirl (new)

$13

Van Leeuwen Vegan HoneyCombe (new)

$13

Vegan

Van Leeuwan Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

$13

Vegan

Van Leuween Vegan Dark Chocolate

$13

Vegan

Van Leeuwen's Vegan Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

$13

Van Leeuwen Rocky Road

$13

candied walnuts, chocolate chip, marshmallow in vegan chocolate ice cream

Little Baby's Chocolate Salt Malt Vegan Ice Cream

$13

Non dairy. Coconut cream kosher salt.

Little Baby's Lychee Lemonade Vegan Ice Cream

$13

Non-dairy. Sweet and tart combination of Lychee and lemonade.

OddFellows Banana Puddin'

$12.95

Eggs, milk, wheat

OddFellows Burnt Marshmallow

$12.95

OddFellows Dark Chocolate Chunk

$12.95

OddFellows Oatmeal Cookie Dough

$12.95

egg, milk, wheat

OddFellows Sprinkles

$11

Vanilla ice cream with sprinkles.

Gimme Smores Ben & Jerry's ice cream (new)

$7.99

Toasted marshmallow ice cream, fudge chunks and Graham crackers

Red Velvet Cake Ice Cream (new)

$7.99

red velvet cake ice cream with red velvet cake pieces and cream cheese frosting swirl! One of the best flavors they have!

Banana Split (new)

$7.99

Banana & strawberry ice cream with walnuts, fudge chunks and fudge swirls.

Americone Dream Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Vanilla ice cream, fudge covered waffle cone pieces and caramel swirl.

Brownie Batter Core

$7.99

Chocolate & Vanilla ice creams with fudge brownies & brownie batter core.

Cherry Garcia

$7.99

The famous Cherry Garcia from Ben & Jerry's

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (new)

$7.99

Vanilla ice cream with gobs of cookie dough.

Chunky Monkey Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Banana ice cream with fudge chunks and walnuts

Chubby Hubby Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Vanilla fudge ice cream, peanutty fudge covered pretzels, peanut buttery swirls.

Half Baked Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Chocolate vanilla ice cream with chocolate cookie dough and fudge brownie

Milk & Cookies Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Vanilla Ice Cream with a Chocolate Cookie Swirl, Chocolate Chip & Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookies

New York Super Fudge Chunk Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Chocolate ice cream, white and dark fudge chunks, peacans, walnuts and fudge covered almonds

Strawberry Cheesecake Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream with Strawberries & a Thick Graham Cracker Swirl

The Tonight Dough Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Caramel & chocolate ice cream, chocolate chip cookie dough & peanut butter cookie dough.

Cinnamom Bun (new) Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Caramel ice cream, cinnamon bun dough and cinnamon streusel swirl

Phish Food Ben & Jerry's ice cream

$7.99

Chocolate ice cream, gooey marshmallow swirls, caramel swirls and fudge fish

Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz Buzz (new)

$7.99

Coffee Ice Cream with Espresso Bean Fudge Chunks

Ben & Jerry's Justice Remix'd (new)

$7.99

Cinnamon & Chocolate Ice Creams with Gobs of Cinnamon Bun Dough & Spicy Fudge Brownies

Maine Lobster Tracks

$12

Vanilla ice cream, lobster-colored chocolate cups filled with caramel all swirled with a unique éclair crunch. RBST free.

Moose Tracks

$13.95

Moose Tracks® fudge swirl and peanut butter mini-cups in smooth vanilla ice cream. RBST free

Chocolate Lover's Chocolate (new)

$13.95

Dark Chocolate ice cream, brownie truffles and double chocolate cookie crunch. Quart

McConnell's Chocolate Chocolate Chocolate! (new)

$14.95

Gluten free nut free creamy chocolate ice cream with Guittard® cocoa house-made chocolate ganache, and melted, bittersweet chocolate chip

McConnell's Sprinkle Cake Ice Cream (new)

$14.95

sheet cake ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. Nut Free

McConnell's Banana & Salted Caramel

$14.95

Ripe bananas, pureed and folded into Central Coast milk & cream, then mated to thick, salt-spiked, deadly delicious, salted caramel sauce.

McConnell's Chocolate Covered Strawberries Ice Cream

$14.95

The richly complex, insanely smooth creaminess of central coast, grass-fed milk and cream, cage-free organic eggs and pure cane sugar - meets its decadent match in Guittard bittersweet, melted chocolate and perfectly ripe, Santa Barbara strawberries.

McConnell's Cookies & Cream

$14.95

Decadent, dense and velvety smooth, Sweet Cream ice cream, paired with rich, chewy chocolate cookies.

McConnell's Double Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream

$14.95

Central coast, grass-fed milk and cream meets savory, salty nuttiness in this especially well-balanced blend of rich, creamy, salty peanut butter folded into smooth and indulgent peanut butter ice cream; includes copious amounts of bittersweet chocolate.

McConnell's Eureka Lemon and Marionberries Ice Cream

$14.95

Glorious, picked-at-their-prime Oregon marion berries, cooked to a jammy perfection and folded into tart and tangy, eureka lemon-infused California central coast, grass-fed milk and cream.

McConnell's Sea Salt Cream and Cookies Ice Cream

$14.95

Dense, velvety smooth and creamy, sweet cream ice cream, a hint of local sea salt and bountiful bits of our chewy, house-made, guittard chocolate chunk cookies.

McConnell's Salted Caramel Chip Ice Cream

$14.95

A uniquely deep and complex salted caramel. Almost toffee-like in flavor, brought together with our stunningly rich mix of cage-free organic eggs, pure cane sugar and fresh, central coast, grass-fed milk and cream, then topped-off by our signature, guittard bittersweet and melted chocolate.

McConnell's Mint Chip

$14.95

Organic peppermint bathed in Central Coast, grass-fed milk & cream and our melted, bittersweet chocolate chip.

McConnell's Pumpkin Pie (new)

$14.95

tastes like pumpkin pie made into an ice cream!

McConnell's Wild Berry Chip (new)

$12

California and Oregon wild berries, cooked-down to an Earth-shatteringly tasty jam, folded into sweet cream ice cream and topped-off with melted, bittersweet chocolate chip. Limited edition

McConnell's Toasted Coconut Almond Chip Ice Cream

$14.95

Shredded coconut, toasted to caramelized perfection, crunchy, salt-roasted almonds and our signature, guittard bittersweet, melted chocolate chip, mated to fresh, California central coast, grass-fed milk and cream.

McConnell's Turkish Coffee Ice Cream

$14.95

A 3-bean selection of espresso and cold-processed coffees delivers all the aroma, smoothness and complex coffee flavor you want, leaving behind any acidity and bitterness. A true coffee fanatics ice cream.

McConnell's Chocolate Almond Brittle Ice Cream

$12

Mouth-filling, medium dark, pure guittard chocolate melted into California central coast, grass-fed milk and cream, then marked by chunks of house made, smokey and salt roasted almond brittle.

Van Leeuwen Peppermint Stick (new)

$12.95

Van Leeuwen Chocolate Fudge Brownie

$12.95

chocolate ice cream, chocolate fudge, brownies

Van Leeuwen Honey Combe (new)

$12.95

Pint. sweet cream base, crunchy, chewy caramel candy

Van Leeuwen Pumpkin Cheese Cake (new)

$12.95

Pint.

Van Leeuwan Mocha Cookie Crumble (new)

$12.95

coffee ice cream, chocolate fudge and speculoos cookies

Van Leeuwen's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

$12.95

Pint.

Van Leeuwan Peanut Butter Marshmallow Crunch

$12.95

Van Leeuwan Pistachio

$12.95

Sour Mix Gummy Candy

$7

1/2 lbs.

Toxic Waste Super Sour Gummy Worms (new)

$7

Insanely sour.

Mini Gummy Sour Sharks (new)

$7

Sour blue sharks. Haribo

Sour Watermellon Gummy Bears (new)

$7

Sour Power Green Apple Candy Belts

$4

Sour apple flavored gummy candy belts. 1/4 lb

Sour Power Berry Blue Candy Belts

$4

Sour Blue Raspberry Gummy Belts 1/4 lb.

Sour Power Quattro belts (new)

$4

sour rainbow 1/4 lb

Sour Power Strawberry Belts

$4

Sour strawberry candy belts gummy. 1/4 lb.

Gimbal's Sour Lips (new)

$7

1/2 lbs. Kosher, Gluten free, Soy free, Egg free

Pink Skulls Swedish (new)

$7

1/2 lb. Sour marshmallow skull with raspberry flavor. No Gelatin. No Corn Syrup.

Sour Swedish Skulls

$7

1/2 lb.

Sour Skulls Mix

$7

1/2 lb. no corn syrup

Sour Peach Lips

$7

1/2 lb.

Mixed Sour Lips

$7

1/2 lb.

Strawberry Logs Sour Swedish Candy

$7

1/2 lbs.

Sours Tongues

$7

1/2 lbs.

1/2 lbs. Gummy Red Hot Chilli Peppers Candy

$7

Hot and spicy

1/2 lbs. Sour Gummy Twin Cherries Candy

$7

Sour Watermellon Gummy Swedish (new)

$7

1/2 lbs. No Gelatin. No Corn Syrup

Sugar Coated Sour Strawberry Gummy Swedish (new)

$7

1/2 lbs. Sour strawberry sugar coated. Gelatin Free. No Corn Syrup.

1/2 lbs. Gummy Sour Creepy Giant Spiders

$7

1/4 lb. Licorice Wild Berry Red Gummy Candy

$3

Sour Cola Bottles

$7

1/2 lbs. Coke flavored. Sugar coated.

Sour Gummy Bears (new)

$7

Blueberry Skulls (new)

$7

blueberry sour gummy. gelatin free. gluten free. Swedish

Watermelon Skulls (new)

$7

Swedish. Gluten free. Gelatin free

Swedish Sour Moons (new)

$7

Sour fruity gummy. Gluten free. Gelatin free

Blueberry Taffy

$7

1/2 lbs. Bluberry flavored.

Blue Raspberry Salt Water Taffy

$7

1/2 lbs.

Chilli Mango Madness Taffy

$7

1/2 lbs. With sweet and heat.

Green Apple Taffy

$7

1/2 lbs.

Orange Salt Water Taffy

$7

1/2 lbs.

Watermelon Taffy

$7

1/2 lbs. Pink and green watermellon taffy.

Pomergranate Taffy

$7