Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery at 126 Rivington St New York, NY 10002
Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery Menu in New York
Promotion
Shot of pudding!
Pudding
$3
Choose your FREE TEASER PUDDING with purchase of $25.00 or more. Make sure to click at checkout to redeem!
The Cast Cupcakes
Sunshine Cupcake
$3.5
Classic yellow cake with vanilla buttercream. Colors for icing vary and so do sprinkles
Black and White Just Right Cupcake
$3.5
Dark chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream. Icing color and sprinkles may vary.
Bob Cupcake
$3.5
Yellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
Ooey Gooey Cupcake
$3.5
Dark chocolate cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
Sexy Red Velvet Cupcake
$3.5
Red velvet cake with satin buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
Sassy Red Velvet Cupcake
$3.5
Red velvet cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
Pistachio Cupcake
$3.5
Pistachio cake with satin buttercream with a pistachio on top.
Pumpkin Cupcake
$3.5
Pumpkin cake with cream cheese icing with a walnut on top.
Oreo Cookie Cupcake
$3.5
Oreo cupcake with satin buttercream with cookie crumble on top.
Lemon Yummy Cupcake
$3.5
Lemon cake with lemon buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
Faux-conut Cupcake
$3.5
Yellow cake with satin buttercream and coconut shreds.
Goodie Goodie Cupcake
$3.5
Dark chocolate cake with whipped peanut butter buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
Strawberry Cupcake with Cream Cheese
$3.5
Strawberry cake with cream cheese icing. Also known as The Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake. Sprinkles may vary. Strawberries on the side, not included.
Strawberry Peanut Butter Cupcake
$3.5
Bits of Strawberry baked into this cupcake with a Whipped Peanut Butter Icing. Also known as the 'Pinch Me Cupcake'. Sprinkles may vary.
Holla Back Girl Cupcake
$3.5
Banana cake with of cream cheese. Sprinkles may vary.
German Chocolate Cupcake
$3.5
This light chocolate cake topped with a coconut, pecan topping is sure to make your taste buds scream, Yummy!
S'mores Cupcake-NEW FLAVOR
$3.75
Chocolate cupcake with our whipped buttercream, graham cracker cookie bottom, marshmallow and a drizzle of chocolate ganache. Good with or without a fire.
4th of July 6 pack - Sunshine Cupcakes
$22
Get your Stars, Stripes, Red, White & Blue on with this Patriotic 6-pack of our classic and definitely NOT boring Vanilla/Vanilla cupcakes.
Mocha Loca Cupcake
$3.25
Coffee cake with whipped chocolate buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
NEW FLAVOR-Pineapple Cupcakes with Vanilla Pineapple Buttercream
$3.25
Chunks of pineapple with creamy and tangy vanilla pineapple buttercream topped with yummy pineapple slice. ooh la la.
German Chocolate Imposter!
$3.5
Once in awhile a sequel is better than the original. Our new version has dark chocolate cake which complements the sweet sticky coconut-y and pecan-y topping to perfection!
The Pudding Posse
Delicious layers of cakes, pudding and cream. Choose from 9 different flavors. Want a little teaser try a shot, maybe you need something for a party go for the 64 oz tub. Whatever to do...choose something. This is a must try!
Banana Pudding
$3
Layers of creamy vanilla pudding, nilla wafers and bananas.
Chocolate Chip Deliciousness
$3
Layers of home made chocolate chip cookies, butterscotch pudding and whip cream.
Chocolate Bomb
$3
Layers of home made dark chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and chocolate whip cream.
Strawberry Lemon Trifle
$3
Layers of our lemon cake, frozen strawberries and whip cream.
The Pina Pudding
$3
This summer favorite is here for but a short time. Layers of vanilla cake, vanilla pudding, pineapple, toasted coconut and whip cream. When it's gone, it's gone till next Summer.
Mint Chocolate Chip Pudding
$3
Made our own mint chocolate chip cookies, layer it with vanilla pudding and mint whip cream.
The Coffee Java Xpress
$3
Layers of our coffee cake, coffee pudding and coffee whip cream.
Awesome Peanut Butter Chocolate Pudding
$3
Layers of home made peanut butter cookies, whipped peanut butter cream and peanut butter whip cream.
Sexy Red Velvet Pudding
$3
Layers of red velvet cake, vanilla pudding, whipped sweetened cream cheese whip cream and pecans.
Schmapple Pudding
$3
Layers of our classic yellow cake, sliced apples, layers of vanilla pudding, caramel whip cream and walnuts.
The Nog
$3
Super moist pumpkin cake with our secret eggnog pudding, whip cream and a dash of nutmeg.
Piggy Puddin' with Nuts - Single Serving
$7
Shortbread crust with layers of scratch chocolate pudding, sweet cream cheese, fresh whip cream and walnuts. Can you say Oink!
Awesome Peanut Butter Chocolate Pudding Shot
$3
Mini Cupcakes
Cakes
4' 2 layer individual cake
Vegan Treats!
check out our growing menu of vegan goodies!
Breakfast items
Other Treats
Slice Lemon Bundt Cake
$4
Classic Lemon Bundt Cake with a lemon drizzle. So yummy with a cup of coffee or milk.
Slice of Pistachio Bundt Cake
$4.85
This amazing pistachio bundt cake is delicious in its simplicity.
Marble Bundt
$4.85
If you like this and that. Then this Marble Bundt cake is right up your alley. A lovely swirl of both vanilla and chocolate cake. Get it before the staff gobbles it up. Perfect afternoon treat with that cup of coffee.
Slice of Coffee Cake
$4.85
This classic coffee cake with cinnamon and walnuts baked in with a sugary walnut top. Was rated as one of New York's best coffee cakes.
Slice of Apple Bundt Cake
$4.85
This staff favorite has chunks of apple baked in.
Baby Lemon Bundt with Lemon Glaze
$4.5
Perfect summer treat! If you want a cake all to yourself and you 'don't want no stinkin' slices' - this is for you!
Whole Coffee Cake
$38
With a cinnamon walnut swirl, what's not to love? Perfect with coffee or without.
Tres leche
$7
Our classic Tres leche with rum! (Contains alcohol.)
Flan
$5.75
Spanish custard with caramel sauce.
Black & White Cake In A Cup
$6
Layers of dark chocolate cake vanilla buttercream and sprinkles all in a cup. Sprinkle combinations may vary.
Sunshine Cake In A Cup
$6
Layers of yellow cake, vanilla buttercream and sprinkles all in a cup.
Whole Apple Bundt
$38
If just one slice of our inescapeable apple cake is not enough...here's the whole bundt and nuthin but the bundt!
Bob Cake In A Cup
$6
Yellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream and sprinkles. Sprinkle combinations may vary.
Ooey Gooey Cake in a Cup
$6
Layers of dark chocolate cake and our classic chocolate almond buttercream. Topped with sprinkles.
Bob Cake BY THE SLICE!!
$7
Our boy next door cake - vanilla cake with chocolate almond buttercream
Banana Nut Bread
$4
This banana nut bread is perfect day or night for a little treat! Enjoy with a glass of milk or with a nice cup of coffee.
Ginger Spice Cake
$3.75
Cinnamon, clove, fresh ginger and some black pepper to add zip to the tongue. Fresh lemon glaze just seals the deal
Homemade Granola - New Item
$6
A chewy, nutty blend of rolled oats, nuts, raisins, coconut, honey and a dash of cinnamon. Perfect snack or mix with your fave yogurt. 12 oz weight.
Piggy Pudding - Contains Nuts
$6
Shortbread crust with layers of scratch chocolate pudding, sweet cream cheese, fresh whip cream and walnuts. Can you say Oink!
Pumpkin Coffee Cake Bundt Slice
$4
World's haven't collided like this since someone accidentally got their chocolate into someone else's peanut butter!
Pumpkin Coffee Cake Bundt with Cinnamon and Walnuts
$4
World's Collide!!!!! Pumpkin Cake AND Coffee Cake???? You won't believe how delicious this is - just try it. Trust.
Red Velvet & Chocolate Chocolate Chip Marble Bundt!
$4
You can't get more chocolate than this! Light Chocolate Red Velvet Cake swirled with our Dark Chocolate cake and studded with our semi-sweet chocolate chips - it's like a party in your mouth!
Red velvet cake by the slice
$6
Succulent Sexy Red Velvet Cake by the slice! Light chocolate red velvet cake with our silky satin buttercream.
SLICE OF CAKE - BLACK & WHITE...JUST RIGHT!
$7
Today's slice-of-the-day is another chocolate fave! The Black & White Cake - dark chocolate cake with sweet buttercream icing! A black & white cookie doesn't stand a chance against this cake!
SLICE OF CAKE - OOEY GOOEY OMG!
$7
Today's Slice-of-the-Day is our most decadent chocolate cake with our trademark chocolate almond buttercream. Are you having one of those days when you need something bigger than just a cupcake? With a chocolate punch? We got you covered.
Slice of Funfetti Cake
$7
Grab a big wedge of this classic piece of Americana cake. Vanilla cake topped with a sugary vanilla buttercream. Put on your party hat, pull out the pin-the-tail on the donkey, pour yourself a big glass of milk (yeah, almond milk is ok) and enjoy! Sprinkles may be different than photo.
Assorted Bars
Lemon Bars
$4
Shortbread crust with just the right amount of lemon to make you pucker!
Oooh Brownies
$4
Espresso chocolate brownie. Rich, rich and rich.
Yum-yum Bars
$4
Shortbread crust layered with semi-sweet chocolate chips, raspberry preserves with a shortbread, chocolate chip crumble. Contains Walnuts.
Hot Out of the Oven Cookies
Flourless Chocolate Chocolate Cookie
$3
This super chocolate cookie has no flour. You won't believe how good it is.
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$0.85
This is that no frills, oversized, over chipped chocolate chip cookie.
Iced Sugar Cookies
$1.75
Classic butter cookie with buttercream and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
Sugar Cookie
$0.85
Classic buttery sugary cookie.
Mint Chocolate Chip Cookie
$0.85
Mint chocolate cookies like those classic thin mint cookies, only better.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$0.85
Classic Oatmeal Raisin Cookie made with all the brown sugar and spice you love!
Sexy Red Velvet Cookies
$0.85
These cookies have a rich cocoa taste that make them sexy on the palate.
Peanut Butter Cookie
$0.85
C'mon - you know these make you feel like a kid again! Plus peanut butter's kinda good for you, right?
Ginger Cookies
$0.85
A zingy, zanger twist of ginger will make you sing for these Ginger Cookies.
Cheesecake
Whole NY Cheesecake
$60
Good old fashion NY Cheesecake with a classic graham cracker crust.
Slice New York Cheesecake
$6
Good old fashion NY Cheesecake with a classic graham cracker crust.
Plain Cheesecake
$3.25
Simple cheesecake with a nilla wafer bottom.
Fancy Schamansey Cheesecake
$3.25
A blueberry and strawberry combo cheesecake with a nilla wafer bottom.
Chocolate Chippie Cheesecake
$3.25
Who doesn't like some chocolate with their cheesecake. Add in some mini chocolate chips and its a score of yumminess! Oh, don't forget the nilla wafer bottom.
Pie
Mini Pies, Pie by the Slice, Whole Pies. Pie, Pie, Pie
Beverages
Poland Springs water 16.9 oz.
Poland Spring Water (Flat)
$1.25
16 oz Poland Spring Flat Water
Beverages
$1.5
Coke, diet coke, flat water
Valentines Day 2020
Valentines Day should be everyday but when you need a little something extra to say, I Really Dig You, or I Love You. We know how to seal the deal with these sweet treats.