The Pony Bar at 637 10th Ave New York, NY 10036


Address: 637 10th Ave New York, NY 10036

Bar Food Sandwiches

The Pony Bar Menu in New York


Sirloin Burger

six ounces, lettuce, tomato & choice of cheese, onion roll.

Roast Chicken

spicy remoulade, parmigiano reggiano cheese, roasted tomatoes, toasted ciabatta.

Sloppy Duck Sliders

pulled duck sliders, cracklings, sloppy sauce, mini potato roll.

Veal Meatball Sandwich

tasty veal orbs, mozzarella-provolone cheese, toasted ciabatta roll.

Roast Beast

house roasted beef, italian seasonings, onion roll.

Short Rib Sandwich

kimchi, hoisin sauce, toasted brioche roll.

Fried Oyster & Bacon

lettuce, spicy tartar sauce, toasted pullman bread.

Braised Lamb Sliders

mascarpone sauce, mini potato roll.

Pulled Pork Sandwich

made with homemade bbq sauce, toasted brioche roll.

Chipotle-Ale Shrimp Torta

spicy shrimp, queso blanco, guacamole, black beans, lettuce, tomato, and chipotle salsa on a toasted roll.

Grilled Cheese

an american classic on toasted pullman bread.


avocado, lettuce, tomato & mayo, toasted ciabatta.

Tasty Plates

Spicy Gumbo

andouille sausage, shrimp, chicken & pulled duck over rice.

Turkey & Black Bean Chili

plum tomatoes, sullivan street bakery bread.

Skillet Sausages

molasses-brown sugar marinade, spicy mustard.

Naked Thai Calamari

sweet chili sauce.

Fish Donuts

cod, corn, bell peppers, matzo crust, capered tartar.

Clams & Sausages

littleneck clams, andouille sausage, beer broth & sullivan street bakery bread.

Deep Fried Adirondack Bill's Horseradish Pickles

chris ryan's raised ranch dressing.

Green Bean Tempura

beer battered green beans, spicy mustard.

Soft Pretzels

baked, beer mustard.

Potato Chips

hand-cut, malt vinegar, sea salt.

On Tap Beers

Hog Heaven

avery. boulder, colorado. a dangerous drinkable graten beauty with ain intense dry-hop nose perfectly balanced with the alcohol content for a caramel candy-like malt backbone.

Titan IPA

great divide. denver colorado. brewed hop disciples; a big, aggressively hopped india pale ale with piney hop aromas and citrus hop flavors, and rich, malty sweetness.

Mama's Little Yella Pils

oskar blues. lynos, colorado. made with hearty amounts of pale malt and bavarian hops, this is the perfect antidote to cure what ails you.

Imperial Pumpkin Ale

weyerbacher. easton, pennsylvania. the mother of all pumpkin ales: heatier, spicier, and more 'caramelly' and 'pumpkin' than its faint brethern!

Mad King's Weiss

victory. downingtown, pennsylvania. high powered with all-german malts and the subtle, spicy complexity of their special yeats - truly thirst-quenching.


troegs. hershey, pennsylvania. contains a blend of locally roasted espresso and kenyan coffee beans, resulting in a lush oatmeal stout mouthfeel.

Original Cider

crispin. minneapolis, minnesota. fruit forward, with a fresh, crunchy apple nose and a delicious creamy, refreshingly crisp mouth feel.

Pumpkin Ale

captain lawrence. elmsford, new york. brewed with pureed pumpkins and traditional pumpkin pie spices, this beer packs a ton of flavor into a malty and smooth amber colored ale.

Dorado Double IPA

ballast point. san diego, california. an award winning beer that embodies san diego's reputation for making world class ipas that accentuate the delightfully aromatic and flavorful qualities of hops.

Milk Stout Nitro

left hand. longmont, colorado. the aroma is of brown sugar and vanilla cream, with hints of roasted coffee, and initial roasty, mocha flavors rise up, with slight hop & roast bitterness in the finish.


bear republic. healdsburg, california. a dry, tart and slightly sour berliner-style wheat beer spontaneously fermented in a 2500 gallon oak vessel.

Scythe And Sickle

ommegang. cooperstown, new york. this amber ale honors the harvest season and brings the mood of fall to life with vibrant and flavorful passion by using barley, oats, wheat, and rye.

Hot Burning Love

barrier. oceanside, new york. this amber ale is dry hopped with glacier hops and was brewed with habanero, jalapeno, and trinidad scorpion peppers.


ramstein. butlet, new jersey. recreation of an authentic german oktoberfest beer from the early 1900s. this amber lager has a rich malty aroma, a smooth tasty palate, and subtle noble hop finish.

Fat Scotsman

adirondack. lake george, new york. this big, full-bodied, malty scotch ale goes through a long kettle caramelization and has a nice, sweet roastiness.


pyramid. seattle, washington. an award-winning american-style wheat ale with a unique take on the bavarian classic; refreshingly unfiltered wheat with a distinctively smoothe flavor.

Hidden Star Cider

slyboro cider house. granville, new york. made from local northern spy and liberty apples; clean, crisp, aromatic and refreshingly smooth, like a ripe apple just pickled from a tree.

Dirtwolf Double IPA

victory. downingtown, pennsylvania. wildly assertive, intentionally untamed and dangerously satisfying; brewed with citra, chinook, simcoe, and mosaic hops.


boulder brewing. boulder, colorado. fresh off the bine colorado hops provide tropical fruit notes while generous amounts of toasted rye bring a spicy, nutty flavor to this delicious party.

Spice Of Life - Ahtanum

sixpoint. brooklyn, new york. the ahtanum hops in this batch of thier single hop ipa series are floral and citrus with a hint of grapefruit and piney, earthy notes.

Flying Dog

frederick, maryland. this firkin of their flagship pale ale is dry-hopped with citra hops for an added citrus aroma.

Doggie Style Pale Ale

frederick, maryland. this firkin of their flagship pale ale is dry-hopped with citra hops for an added citrus aroma.